Reid v. Fargo
Citations
- 241 U.S. 544
- 36 S. Ct. 712
- 60 L. Ed. 1156
- 1916 U.S. LEXIS 1676
Syllabus
<p>In the Second Circuit, the practice is well established that an appeal from the decree of the District Court to the Circuit Court of Appeals in an admiralty case by one of the parties opens the case for a trial de novo. Irvine v. The Hesper, 122 U. S. 256.</p> <p>The owner of an automobile delivered it to an express company in London to forward to New York, declaring its value to be far in excess of $100; the express company boxed it and delivered it to a carrier and accepted a bill of lading with a limitation of $100 liability; on arrival at destination a stevedore discharged the cargo and the rope by which the automobile was being hoisted broke and the automobile was seriously damaged: in a suit in personam in admiralty against the express company and to which the carrier and the stevedore had been made parties held that:</p> <p>The breaking of the rope in this case illustrates, as by analogy, the rule of res ipsa loquitur and throws the responsibility on the stevedore furnishing the rope and handling the article, unless such breaking can be explained as resulting from a hidden defect, which in this case is without support in the evidence.</p> <p>The breaking of the rope appearing from the evidence to have probably resulted from straining and cutting, the stevedore was responsible for the damage and the decree should be against him primarily.</p> <p>In case of failure to collect from the stevedore the carrier is responsible to the extent of the limited amount stated in the bill of lading, and in case there is still a deficiency, the express company, even though only a forwarder, is liable by reason of having, without the authority of the shipper and with knowledge of the value of the article entrusted to it, accepted from the carrier a bill of lading limiting its liability.</p>
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- boxed steel roll in wooden case
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: White
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
71 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Langnes v. GreenSupreme Court· 1931-02-24· cited 742×
- Standard Oil Co. of NJ v. Southern Pacific Co.Supreme Court· 1925-04-20· cited 256×
- Robert C. Herd & Co. v. Krawill MacHinery Corp.Supreme Court· 1959-04-20· cited 250×
- George v. Bekins Van & Storage Co.California Supreme Court· 1949-05-13· cited 113×
- Ricardo Fotys Caradelis v. Refineria Panama, S. A.Fifth Circuit· 1967-10-04· cited 68×
- Standard Electrica, S.A. v. Hamburg Sudamerikanische Dampfschifffahrts-Gesellschaft, Defendant-Appellee,and Columbus Lines, Inc.Second Circuit· 1967-04-19· cited 66×
- Unnamed caseSecond Circuit· 1981-01-16· cited 59×
- Mitsui & Co. v. American Export Lines, Inc.Second Circuit· 1981-01-16· cited 47×
- The Ernest H. MeyerNinth Circuit· 1936-06-10· cited 43×
- A. M. Collins & Co. v. Panama R. Co.Fifth Circuit· 1952-07-31· cited 42×
- United States v. LarneyUnited States Court of Military Appeals· 1953-05-29· cited 36×
- Untersinger v. United StatesSecond Circuit· 1950-05-03· cited 33×
- Burke v. . Union Pacific R.R. Co.New York Court of Appeals· 1919-07-15· cited 33×
- Hartford Fire Insurance Company v. Pacific Far East Line, Inc.Ninth Circuit· 1974-02-04· cited 31×
- T. M. Duche & Sons, Ltd. v. American Schooner \John Twohy\Supreme Court· 1921-02-28· cited 29×
- Mitsubishi International Corporation, Libellant-Appellant v. S.S. Palmetto State and States Marine Corporation of DelawareSecond Circuit· 1962-12-04· cited 24×
- Ingersoll Milling MacHine Co. v. M/V BodenaS.D. New York· 1985-09-04· cited 21×
- Wilbanks & Pierce, Inc. v. HendryFifth Circuit· 1945-07-10· cited 20×
- Commonwealth Petrochemicals, Inc. v. S/S Puerto RicoFourth Circuit· 1979-09-19· cited 19×
- Frederick Leyland & Co. v. HornblowerFirst Circuit· 1919-02-11· cited 18×
Other cases named Reid v. Fargo
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.