Arizona Supreme Court· 10/31/1991
Read v. Phoenix Newspapers, Inc.
Citations
- 819 P.2d 939
- 169 Ariz. 353
- 19 Media L. Rep. (BNA) 1563
- 98 Ariz. Adv. Rep. 24
- 1991 Ariz. LEXIS 84
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- determination of substantial truth looks at whether the literal truth would have made a material difference
- “Slight inaccuracies will not prevent a statement from being true in substance, as long as the ‘gist’ or ‘sting’ of the publication is justified.”
- “Substantial truth is an absolute defense to a 28 1 defamation action in Arizona.”
- “Substantial truth is an absolute defense to a defamation action in Arizona. 2 Slight inaccuracies will not prevent a statement from being true in substance, as long as the 3 ‘gist’ or ‘sting’ of the publication is justified.”
- “Substantial truth 6 is an absolute defense to a defamation action in Arizona. Slight inaccuracies will not 7 prevent a statement from being true in substance, as long as the ‘gist’ or ‘sting’ of the 8 publication is justified.”
- “We conclude that the ‘sting’ of the two versions is not substantially different and therefore, had the published statements contained an accurate account 2 of the conviction and sentence, there would not have been any less damage to Read’s reputation.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Gordon, Feldman, Cameron, Moeller, Corcoran
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
15 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Huckabee v. Time Warner Entertainment Co.Texas Supreme Court· 2000-05-04· cited 260×
- Medical Laboratory Management Consultants v. American Broadcasting CompaniesD. Arizona· 1998-12-22· cited 28×
- Takieh M.D. v. O'Meara M.D.Court of Appeals of Arizona· 2021-08-10· cited 25×
- Barnett v. Denver Pub. Co., Inc.Colorado Court of Appeals· 2001-04-26· cited 23×
- Currier v. Western Newspapers, Inc.Arizona Supreme Court· 1993-07-20· cited 16×
- Hartzell v. Marana Unified School DistrictNinth Circuit· 2025-03-05· cited 8×
- Chilton v. Center for Biological Diversity, Inc.Court of Appeals of Arizona· 2006-12-06· cited 5×
- Blk III, LLC v. SkeltonCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2022-02-17· cited 5×
- Pinal County v. CooperCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2015-10-20· cited 5×
- Lundin v. Discovery Commc'ns Inc.D. Arizona· 2018-11-02· cited 5×
- Brandon Darby v. the New York Times Company and James C. McKinley, Jr.Tex. App. Ct., 14th Dist. (Houston)· 2015-02-04
- Rogers v. Hon MrozCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2020-12-08
- John Doe v. MahoneyCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2018-02-06
- Patterson v. Atlantic Research Marketing Systems, Inc.Ninth Circuit· 2002-06-27
- Thompson v. Dignity HealthD. Arizona· 2019-03-05
Cites
12 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Orme School v. ReevesArizona Supreme Court· 1990-12-06· cited 801×
- Mark v. Seattle TimesWashington Supreme Court· 1981-11-12· cited 198×
- Harlan E. Orr v. The Argus-Press CompanySixth Circuit· 1978-10-19· cited 110×
- Wayne R. Anderson v. Willow L. Cramlet, the Arvada Sentinel, and Donald GorehamTenth Circuit· 1986-04-29· cited 61×
- Fendler v. Phoenix Newspapers, Inc.Court of Appeals of Arizona· 1981-11-03· cited 53×
- Hall v. Motorists Insurance CorporationArizona Supreme Court· 1973-05-07· cited 32×
- Archie E. Simonson v. United Press International, Inc., and the Associated Press, Inc.Seventh Circuit· 1981-07-16· cited 29×
- Hovey v. Iowa State Daily Publication Board, Inc.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1985-07-31· cited 20×
- Heuisler v. Phoenix Newspapers, Inc.Court of Appeals of Arizona· 1991-03-05· cited 17×
- Hopkins v. KeithLouisiana Court of Appeal· 1977-06-22· cited 16×
- Huff v. Bekins Moving & Storage Co.Court of Appeals of Arizona· 1985-01-25· cited 8×
- Read v. Phoenix Newspapers, Inc.Court of Appeals of Arizona· 1990-10-30· cited 4×
Other cases named Read v. Phoenix Newspapers, Inc.
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.