First Circuit· 8/25/2015
Ray, III v. Ropes & Gray LLP
Citations
- 799 F.3d 99
- 2015 U.S. App. LEXIS 15026
- 127 Fair Empl. Prac. Cas. (BNA) 1606
- 2015 WL 5011753
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- noting that the “probative value” of racially derogatory marks is “circumscribed if they were made in a situation temporally remote from the date of the employment decision in question” (citation omitted)
- noting that while a plaintiff may make a showing of discrimination by pointing to similarly situated employees who were treated differently, the compared employees must “closely resemble one another in respect to relevant facts and circumstances” (quotation omitted)
- indicating that a rationale is pretextual when it is a “sham”
- stating that opining on the employee’s “fit into the culture of the firm” did not show animus where the evidence showed the phrase was regularly used to discuss the employee’s ability to solicit business and work collegially with other staff
- observing, in Title VII retaliation claim, that “[u]nlike the reasonableness requirement, when assessing a plaintiff’s good faith a factfinder need only ask whether a plaintiff had a subjective, honestly held belief”
- stating litigant waived his right to object to an instruction he \affirmatively requested\
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Howard, Lipez, Thompson
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
45 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Theriault v. Genesis Healthcare LLCFirst Circuit· 2018-05-16· cited 136×
- John Edwards v. Department of LaborMerit Systems Protection Board· 2022-05-05· cited 130×
- Theidon v. Harvard UniversityFirst Circuit· 2020-01-31· cited 98×
- Audette v. Town of PlymouthFirst Circuit· 2017-05-26· cited 59×
- Stratton v. Bentley UniversityFirst Circuit· 2024-08-15· cited 50×
- Caraballo-Caraballo v. Administracion de CorreccionFirst Circuit· 2018-06-08· cited 48×
- Rodriguez v. United StatesFirst Circuit· 2017-03-24· cited 46×
- Brader v. Biogen Inc.First Circuit· 2020-12-18· cited 45×
- Frith v. Whole Foods Market, Inc.First Circuit· 2022-06-28· cited 43×
- Paul v. MurphyFirst Circuit· 2020-01-24· cited 39×
- Benson v. Wal-Mart Stores East L.P.First Circuit· 2021-09-15· cited 38×
- Sheridan v. Centerra Group, LLCFirst Circuit· 2024-06-28· cited 34×
- Trahan v. Wayfair Maine LLCFirst Circuit· 2020-04-21· cited 33×
- Rae v. Woburn Public SchoolsFirst Circuit· 2024-08-22· cited 30×
- Harley-Davidson Credit Corp. v. GalvinFirst Circuit· 2015-12-08· cited 28×
- Kinzer v. Whole Foods Market, Inc.First Circuit· 2024-04-24· cited 24×
- Colman v. FaucherD. Rhode Island· 2015-09-11· cited 20×
- Marzuq v. Cadete Enterprises, Inc.First Circuit· 2015-12-09· cited 17×
- Brandt v. FitzpatrickFirst Circuit· 2020-04-22· cited 16×
- Anderson v. BrennanFirst Circuit· 2018-12-14· cited 12×
Cites
50 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. GreenSupreme Court· 1973-05-14· cited 38,518×
- Reeves v. Sanderson Plumbing Products, Inc.Supreme Court· 2000-06-12· cited 12,455×
- City of St. Louis v. PraprotnikSupreme Court· 1988-03-02· cited 3,553×
- Theodore L. Leblanc v. Great American Insurance CompanyFirst Circuit· 1993-09-29· cited 922×
- Crawford v. Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson Cty.Supreme Court· 2009-01-26· cited 768×
- The Dartmouth Review, on Behalf of Its Officers, Staff and Subscribers v. Dartmouth CollegeFirst Circuit· 1989-11-09· cited 675×
- Joann S. Reed, Plaintiff-Appellee-Cross-Appellant v. A.W. Lawrence & Co., Inc., Defendant-Appellant-Cross-AppelleeSecond Circuit· 1996-09-11· cited 519×
- Wilma Cumpiano A/K/A Wilma Cumpiano Sanchez v. Banco Santander Puerto RicoFirst Circuit· 1990-05-04· cited 396×
- Fantini v. Salem State CollegeFirst Circuit· 2009-02-23· cited 357×
- Eric H. Deravin, III v. Bernard Kerik, Commissioner, and New York City Department of CorrectionsSecond Circuit· 2003-07-11· cited 347×
- Benoit v. Technical Manufacturing Corp.First Circuit· 2003-06-09· cited 298×
- Dr. Joy HOCHSTADT, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. WORCESTER FOUNDATION FOR EXPERIMENTAL BIOLOGY Et Al., Defendants-AppelleesFirst Circuit· 1976-09-24· cited 277×
- Harlow v. Children's HospitalFirst Circuit· 2005-12-20· cited 266×
- Mariani-Colón v. Department of Homeland SecurityFirst Circuit· 2007-12-18· cited 242×
- Kosereis v. Department forFirst Circuit· 2003-06-12· cited 237×
- Educadores Puertorriqueños en Acción v. HernándezFirst Circuit· 2004-05-10· cited 230×
- Charles PAYNE, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. McLEMORE’S WHOLESALE & RETAIL STORES, a Louisiana Corporation, Defendant-AppellantFifth Circuit· 1981-09-04· cited 220×
- Sias v. City Demonstration AgencyNinth Circuit· 1978-11-08· cited 205×
- Surprenant v. RivasFirst Circuit· 2005-09-09· cited 188×
- Claire A. Straughn v. Delta Air Lines, Inc.First Circuit· 2001-12-05· cited 187×
Other cases named Ray, III v. Ropes & Gray LLP
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.