Producers Coke Co. v. Hoover
Citations
- 268 Pa. 104
- 110 A. 733
- 1920 Pa. LEXIS 634
Syllabus
<p>Contract — Sale—Evidence—Parol evidence — Burden of proof— Modification of written contract — Sales Act of May 19, 1915, P. L. 51fS — Consideration—Part performance.</p> <p>1. It is a general rule at common law that the parties to a written agreement may modify it by a subsequent parol agreement.</p> <p>2. Under the Sales Act of May 19, 1915, P. L. 543, a parol modification of a written contract for the sale of goods exceeding in amount $500, is valid, if the modified agreement is acted upon and partly performed.</p> <p>3. In an action for a breach of a written contract for the sale of coke in amount in excess of $500, the vendor, the defendant, may prove not only that the written contract had been modified by a parol agreement to accept less coke, but also that for seven months thereafter coke had been delivered, accepted and paid for under the modified agreement. The burden of proof is on defendant to prove the modification of the contract and part performance of the modified contract.</p> <p>4. In such case, evidence that plaintiff, during the seven months after the modification of the original contract, bought other coke of defendant at the market price, is relevant only as tending to show a modification of the original contract.</p> <p>5. The consideration for the modified contract, as well as the original contract, is the mutual obligations of the parties.</p> <p>6. Part performance will validate a parol contract for the sale of personalty.</p>
Judges: Brown, Frazer, Kephart, Moschzisker, Simpson, Stewart, Walling
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
7 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Continental Collieries, Inc. v. ShoberThird Circuit· 1942-09-14· cited 194×
- Manufacturers Light & Heat Co. v. LampSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1921-02-28· cited 41×
- Ashley and Gibbs v. PrestonTennessee Supreme Court· 1931-06-10· cited 21×
- MacY v. OSWALD Et Ux.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1962-06-13· cited 12×
- Macy v. OswaldSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1962-06-13· cited 10×
- Roberts v. CauffielBlair County Court of Common Pleas· 1925-07-01· cited 1×
- Du Bois v. ZimmermanThird Circuit· 1928-09-20
Cites
16 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Achenbach v. StoddardSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1916-04-17· cited 40×
- Rucker v. HarringtonMissouri Court of Appeals· 1893-01-16· cited 36×
- Flegal v. HooverSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1893-07-19· cited 35×
- Mills v. HuntNew York Supreme Court· 1838-12-15· cited 31×
- Malone v. PhiladelphiaSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1892-02-22· cited 21×
- Robert Grace Contracting Co. v. Norfolk & Western Railway Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1918-01-07· cited 20×
- Germantown Dairy Co. v. McCallumSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1909-03-01· cited 16×
- Willis v. FieldsSupreme Court of Georgia· 1909-02-27· cited 9×
- Espy v. AndersonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1850-10-21· cited 8×
- Flannery v. WesselsSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1914-03-02· cited 8×
- Wilgus v. WhiteheadSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1879-03-03· cited 6×
- Reber v. BrownbackSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1905-03-14· cited 6×
- Carrier & Baum v. DilworthSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1868-11-06· cited 5×
- Rutherford v. SampleMissouri Court of Appeals· 1914-12-12· cited 5×
- Musselman v. StonerSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1858-07-01· cited 3×
- Swigart v. McGeeSupreme Court of Arkansas· 1858-01-15· cited 3×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.