Pollock v. Farmers' Loan & Trust Co.

Citations

• 157 U.S. 429
• 15 S. Ct. 673
• 39 L. Ed. 759
• 1895 U.S. LEXIS 2215
• 3 A.F.T.R. (P-H) 2557

Syllabus

<p>A court of equity has jurisdiction to prevent a threatened breach of trust in the misapplication or diversion of the funds of a corporation by illegal payments out of its capital or profits.</p> <p>Such a bill being filed by a stockholder to prevent a trust company from voluntarily making returns for the imposition and payment of a tax claimed to be unconstitutional, and on the further ground of threatened multiplicity of suits and irreparable injury, and the objection of adequate' remedy at law not having been raised below or in this court, and the question of jurisdiction having been waived by'the United States, so far as it was within its power to do so, and the relief sofight being to prevent the voluntary action of the trust company and not introspect to the assessment and collection of the tax, the court will proceed to judgment on the merits.</p> <p>The doctrine of stare decisis is a salutary one, and is to be adhered to on proper occasions, in respect of decisions directly upon points in issue; but this court should' not extend any decision upon a constitutional question,, if it .is convinced that error in principle might Supervene,</p> <p>Xn the cases referred to in the opinion of the court in this case, beginning with Hylton v. United States, 3 Dall. 171, (February Term, 1796,) and ending with Springer v. United States, 102 U. S. 586, (October Term, 1880,) taxes on land are conceded to be direct taxes, and in none of them is it determined that a tax on rent or income derived from land is not a tax on laud.</p> <p>A tax on the rents or income of real estate is a direct tax, within the meaning of that term as used in the Constitution of the United States.</p> <p>A tax upon income derived from the interest of bonds issued by a municipal corporation is a tax upon the power of the State and its instrumentalities to borrow money, and is consequently repugnant to the Constitution of the United States.</p> <p>So much of the act “ to reduce taxation, to provide