Philadelphia v. Bilyeu
Citations
- 36 Pa. Super. 562
- 1908 Pa. Super. LEXIS 204
Syllabus
<p>Practice, C. P. — Trial—Motion for judgment non obstante veredicto —Points for charge — Act of April 22,1905, P. L. 286.</p> <p>Under the Act of April 22, 1905, P. L. 286, a party has no standing to move for judgment non .obstante veredicto upon the whole record, where he has not at the trial presented a point requesting binding instructions in his favor.</p> <p>Practice, C. P. — Trial—Reservation of question of law — Acts of March 28,1835, P. L. 88, and April 22,1863, P; L. 554.</p> <p>A party is not entitled to have reviewed the action of the lower court in refusing a motion for judgment non obstante veredicto upon a question of law reserved, where no exception is taken to such action of the court below.</p> <p>Road law — Paving—Assessment bills — Defenses—Act of April 19, 1843, P. L. 342.</p> <p>Where a city ordinance provides a particular grade for gutters, and for the crown of the pavement in grading and paving streets, unless the chief engineer and surveyors shall certify otherwise, and a contract is entered into by the city with a contractor in accordance with- the terms of the ordinance, the contractor cannot recover the amount of an assessment bill' against an abutting owner, where it appears that during the progress of the work the chief of the highway bureau changed the grade of the gutter and crown so that when the work was finished there was no gutter on one side of the street, and the slope of the pavement was such that the abutting owner suffered a special injury in having all the surface drainage thrown on his side of the street, and there stagnating without being carried to a sewer inlet. In such a case the owner is not estopped because he did not object while the work was under way where he had no knowledge whatever that the chief engineer and surveyor had not certified to the change in the specifications of the contract; nor is the owner barred from setting up as a defense his special injury, because the work had been accepted by the city offic
Judges: Beaver, Head, Henderson, Morrison, Orlady, Rice
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
5 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Haley v. American Agricultural Chemical Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1909-04-12· cited 6×
- International Savings & Trust Co. v. PrintzSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1908-10-12· cited 6×
- Philadelphia v. BilyeuSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1911-07-13· cited 5×
- Pennsylvania Railroad v. HarlSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1912-05-13· cited 1×
- Trudnak v. LilleyUnion County Court of Common Pleas· 1986-03-14· cited 1×
Cites
20 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Reel v. ElderSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1869-07-06· cited 96×
- Pepper v. City of Philadelphia ex rel. HorterSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1886-10-04· cited 29×
- Erie City v. ButlerSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1888-05-14· cited 24×
- Miller v. HersheySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1868-05-18· cited 22×
- City ex rel. O'Rourke v. HaysSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1880-01-30· cited 17×
- McKnight v. City of PittsburghSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1879-10-27· cited 15×
- Craig v. City of PhiladelphiaSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1879-05-07· cited 11×
- Philadelphia v. JewellSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1890-05-26· cited 11×
- City of Philadelphia ex rel. Mack v. GorgasSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1897-03-15· cited 11×
- Wickham v. TwaddellSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1904-05-19· cited 9×
- Reilly v. City of PhiladelphiaSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1869-05-11· cited 8×
- Pittsburg v. WalterSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1871-10-23· cited 8×
- Philadelphia v. PembertonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1904-02-29· cited 8×
- City of Harrisburg v. SheplerSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1898-07-29· cited 7×
- Commissioners of District of Kensington v. KeithSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1845-12-15· cited 6×
- Central Bank v. EarleySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1886-10-04· cited 6×
- Philadelphia ex rel. Dyer v. BrookeSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1876-02-07· cited 4×
- City of Erie v. Piece of Land Fronting on Eighteenth StreetSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1895-11-04· cited 4×
- Wabash AvenueSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1904-10-17· cited 2×
- Yard v. PancoastSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1885-02-02· cited 1×
Other cases named Philadelphia v. Bilyeu
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.