Phenix Ins. v. Kerr
Citations
- 129 F. 723
- 66 L.R.A. 569
- 1904 U.S. App. LEXIS 4090
Syllabus
<p>1. Practice — Peremptory Instructions — Waiver of Jury.</p> <p>Where at the close of a trial to a jury each party requests a peremptory instruction in his favor, and the court grants one of the requests, that ruling constitutes a general finding for the successful party by the court, and the only questions it presents in an appellate court are. was the finding without substantial evidence to support it? and, was there error in the court’s declaration or application of the law?</p> <p>2. Insurance — Unconditional Ownership — Purchaser under Contract Has.</p> <p>The interest of a purchaser of property, which he has unqualifiedly agreed to buy and which the former owner has absolutely contracted to sell to him upon definite terms, is the sole and unconditional ownership within the true meaning of the ordinary clause upon that subject in insurance policies, because the vendor may compel the vendee to pay for the property and to suffer any loss that occurs.</p> <p>3. Same — Option to Purchase — Unconditional Ownership.</p> <p>The interest of an owner of property which another holds under his option to purchase, which is irrevocable by the owner, but which the holder of the option has not bound himself to accept, and which he is free to abandon, is the sole and unconditional ownership of the property within the proper interpretation of the clause upon that subject in insurance policies, because the owner cannot compel the holder of the option to take the property or suffer the loss.</p> <p>4. Same — Proofs of Loss — Denial of Contract — Waiver of Proofs.</p> <p>A distinct denial by an insurance company of liability under a policy after the loss, and within the time prescribed for the proofs, upon the ground that there was no contract of insurance, is a waiver of proofs of loss, because in such a case the proofs do not tend to induce the company to pay the loss, and they are futile.</p> <p>(Syllabus by the Court.)</p> <p>If 2. See Insurance, vol. 28, Cent. Dig. §§ 347,
Judges: Sanborn
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
28 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Minahan v. Grand Trunk Western Ry. Co.Sixth Circuit· 1905-06-15· cited 50×
- Horgan v. RussellNorth Dakota Supreme Court· 1913-02-05· cited 42×
- Rokey v. Day & Zimmermann, Inc.Eighth Circuit· 1946-11-08· cited 30×
- Nelson v. FergusonThird Circuit· 1932-02-02· cited 29×
- Connecticut Fire Insurance v. Colorado Leasing, Mining & Milling Co.Supreme Court of Colorado· 1911-04-15· cited 25×
- Buckbee v. P. Hohenadel, Jr., Co.Seventh Circuit· 1915-01-05· cited 25×
- Crowley v. ByrneWashington Supreme Court· 1912-12-28· cited 21×
- Empire State Cattle Co. v. Atchison, T. & S. F. Ry. Co.Eighth Circuit· 1906-07-09· cited 19×
- Michigan Home Colony Co. v. TaborEighth Circuit· 1905-11-17· cited 17×
- Philadelphia v. Philadelphia Transportation Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1956-10-18· cited 14×
- Mark v. Liverpool & London & Globe InsuranceSupreme Court of Minnesota· 1924-05-09· cited 13×
- Bright v. Hanover Fire InsuranceWashington Supreme Court· 1907-12-10· cited 12×
- Cascade Auto Co. v. PetterSupreme Court of Colorado· 1923-02-05· cited 11×
- Meyer & Chapman State Bank v. First Nat. BankEighth Circuit· 1923-06-15· cited 11×
- National Fire Insurance Company of Hartford v. The Board of Public Instruction of Madison County, Florida, and J. C. ThomasFifth Circuit· 1957-01-08· cited 10×
- Clapper v. GambleEighth Circuit· 1928-09-28· cited 10×
- Ruston Drilling Co. v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co.Eighth Circuit· 1936-02-27· cited 10×
- R. Olsen Oil Co. v. Fidler. Fidler v. R. Olsen Oil CoTenth Circuit· 1952-10-29· cited 9×
- First Nat. Bank of Wagener v. Glens Falls Ins. Co. of Glen FallsFourth Circuit· 1928-06-12· cited 9×
- Springfield Fire & Marine Ins. Co. v. National Fire Ins. Co.Eighth Circuit· 1931-07-20· cited 8×
Cites
15 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Beuttell v. MagoneSupreme Court· 1895-03-11· cited 155×
- Beuttell v. MagoneSupreme Court· 1895-12-19· cited 149×
- Richardson v. HardwickSupreme Court· 1882-11-27· cited 92×
- Hough v. City Fire InsuranceSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1860-02-15· cited 74×
- Laing v. RigneySupreme Court· 1896-01-13· cited 73×
- Wainer v. Milford Mutual Fire InsuranceMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1891-02-27· cited 43×
- Gustin v. Union School-DistrictMichigan Supreme Court· 1893-01-20· cited 40×
- Stanford v. McGillNorth Dakota Supreme Court· 1897-11-01· cited 28×
- United States v. BishopEighth Circuit· 1903-09-07· cited 26×
- Amsinck v. American InsuranceMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1880-07-10· cited 19×
- Merwin v. MagoneSecond Circuit· 1895-12-02· cited 19×
- Kerr v. Milwaukee Mechanics' Ins.Eighth Circuit· 1902-08-25· cited 17×
- Rumsey v. Phœnix InsuranceU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Northern New York· 1880-02-28· cited 11×
- Dupuy v. Delaware Ins. Co. of PhiladelphiaU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Western Virginia· 1894-09-21· cited 9×
- King v. SmithNinth Circuit· 1901-08-19· cited 7×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.