Pettigrew v. Pettigrew
Citations
- 207 Pa. 313
- 56 A. 878
- 1904 Pa. LEXIS 471
Syllabus
<p>Burial of the dead—General rules on the subject—Surviving husband— Widow—Next of kin—Reinterment.</p> <p>There is no universal rule as to the burial of the dead applicable alike to all cases, but each case must be considered in equity on its own merits having due regard to the interest of the public, the wishes of the decedent, and the rights and feelings of those entitled to be heard by reason of relationship or association.</p> <p>Subject to this general result it may be laid down first, that the paramount right is in the surviving husband or widow, and if the parties were living in the normal relations of marriage it will require a very strong case to justify a court in interfering with the wish of the survivor.</p> <p>Secondly, if there is no surviving husband or wife, the right is in the next of kin in the order of their relation to the decedent, as children of proper age, parents, brothers and sisters, or more distant kin, modified it may be by circumstances of special intimacy or association with the decedent.</p> <p>Thirdly, how far the desires of the decedent should prevail against those of a surviving husband or wife is an open question, but as against remoter connections, such wishes especially if strongly and recently expressed, should usually prevail.</p> <p>Fourthly, with regard to a reinterment in a different place, the same rules should apply, but with a presumption against removal growing stronger with the remoteness of connection with the decedent and reserving always the right of the court to require reasonable cause to be shown for it.</p> <p>A decedent left a widow and one child, his next of kin, to survive him. He was buried in a lot belonging to his father’s family, with the widow’s consent, but whethef her consent was more than for a temporary interment was disputed. Decedent’s child died about a year afterwards and was buried in a lot purchased by the widow in another cemetery. The daughter, though young, appears to have had a sentiment o
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- stating “the wishes of the spouse seem to command first consideration”
- “if the parties were living in the normal relations of marriage it will require a very strong case to justify a court in interfering with the wish of the survivor”
- \if the parties were living in the normal relations of marriage it will require a very strong case to justify a court in interfering with the wish of the survivor\
- “It is commonly said, being repeated from the early cases in England, where the whole matter of burials was under the jurisdiction of the ecclesiastical courts, that there can be no property in a corpse.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Brown, Dean, Fell, Mestrezat, Mitchell, Potter
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
69 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Brown v. Matthews Mortuary, Inc.Idaho Supreme Court· 1990-11-15· cited 47×
- Whitehair v. Highland Memory Gardens, Inc.West Virginia Supreme Court· 1985-03-01· cited 41×
- Linda F. Seals v. H & F, Inc.Tennessee Supreme Court· 2010-01-15· cited 39×
- Steagall v. Doctors Hospital, Inc.D.C. Circuit· 1948-12-20· cited 21×
- Goldman v. MollenSupreme Court of Virginia· 1937-06-10· cited 19×
- Sacred Heart of Jesus Polish National Catholic Church v. SoklowskiSupreme Court of Minnesota· 1924-05-16· cited 18×
- Novelli v. CarrollSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1980-04-25· cited 17×
- Swidzinski v. SchultzSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1985-05-17· cited 16×
- North East Coal Co. v. PickelsimerCourt of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976)· 1934-02-20· cited 16×
- Leschey v. LescheySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1953-06-26· cited 15×
- John Thorpe v. Borough of Jim ThorpeThird Circuit· 2014-10-23· cited 15×
- In re the Estate of JohnsonNew York Surrogate's Court· 1938-09-12· cited 14×
- Mutual Life Ins. Co. v. GriesaU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Kansas· 1907-09-14· cited 13×
- Sherman v. ShermanNew Jersey Superior Court App Division· 1999-07-25· cited 12×
- Hickey v. HickeyIndiana Court of Appeals· 1973-06-29· cited 12×
- Lengyel v. BohrerSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1953-02-13· cited 12×
- Barbara Sullivan v. Catholic Cemeteries, Inc.Supreme Court of Rhode Island· 1974-04-11· cited 11×
- Estes v. Woodlawn Memorial Park, Inc.Court of Appeals of Tennessee· 1989-09-22· cited 11×
- Wood v. E. R. Butterworth & SonsWashington Supreme Court· 1911-10-16· cited 11×
- Hood v. SprattMississippi Supreme Court· 1978-04-05· cited 10×
Cites
2 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Other cases named Pettigrew v. Pettigrew
4 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.