People v. . McElvaine
Citations
- 26 N.E. 929
- 125 N.Y. 596
- 8 N.Y. Crim. 156
- 36 N.Y. St. Rep. 180
- 80 Sickels 596
- 1891 N.Y. LEXIS 1521
Syllabus
<p>Where upon the whole case it appears upon a criminal trial that defendant had sufficient intelligence and self control to understand the nature and character of the act committed by him and to refrain from its commission if found to be inconsistent with a due regard for Ms own safety or interest, defendant had sufficient mental capacity to make him legally responsible for Ms acts.</p> <p>It is only when the necessity of an examination as to the sanity of a prisoner is sufficiently made to appear to the court in which the indictment is pending that it is bound to order an examination; but it would be the plain duty of a court when the subject is brought to its attention by responsible parties, to make itself a sufficient inspection and examination to determine whether the application is made in good faith and upon plausible grounds; and the apparent facts thus discovered are made the condition of the right of the court to institute the statutory inquisition.</p> <p>The statute (Code Orim. Proe. § 658) contemplates two cases in which a commission may be appointed to inquire into the sanity of a prisoner: First, after a plea on the merits and before trial, to determine his mental condition at the time of the commission of the crime; and Second, when a person in confinement under indictment whether before or after conviction appears to be insane, to determine his mental condition at the time of the examination.</p> <p>The trial court is invested with a discretion to order such an examination or not as it may from inspection, observation, and information judge to be necessary or expedient.</p>
Judges: Ruger
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
27 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Cooper v. OklahomaSupreme Court· 1996-04-23· cited 861×
- People v. ArmlinNew York Court of Appeals· 1975-06-19· cited 189×
- Murphy v. MassachusettsSupreme Court· 1900-03-01· cited 135×
- People v. GelikkayaNew York Court of Appeals· 1994-12-01· cited 67×
- Youtsey v. United StatesSixth Circuit· 1899-11-13· cited 66×
- McElvaine v. BrushSupreme Court· 1891-12-21· cited 56×
- State v. ShuffIdaho Supreme Court· 1903-05-28· cited 33×
- State v. LyonsSupreme Court of Louisiana· 1904-12-19· cited 26×
- State v. PetersonWashington Supreme Court· 1916-04-01· cited 19×
- People v. CorwiseAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1986-05-12· cited 16×
- People v. FarmerNew York Court of Appeals· 1909-02-09· cited 14×
- People ex rel. Klesitz v. MillsNew York Supreme Court· 1942-07-30· cited 9×
- People v. ColvilleAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1980-03-31· cited 7×
- People v. FloraAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1953-03-11· cited 6×
- People v. HillAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1959-12-29· cited 6×
- People v. IrwinNew York Court of General Session of the Peace· 1938-03-08· cited 6×
- People ex rel. Apicella v. Superintendent of Kings County HospitalNew York Supreme Court· 1940-02-26· cited 5×
- People v. NyhanNew York Supreme Court· 1918-07-16· cited 5×
- People v. WhitmanNew York Court of General Session of the Peace· 1933-10-13· cited 5×
- State v. JacobWashington Supreme Court· 1924-12-01· cited 3×
Cites
2 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.