Pearson v. Zehr
Citations
- 125 Ill. 573
- 18 N.E. 204
Syllabus
<p>1. Appeal—whether the validity of a statute is involved. An appeal lies from the trial court directly to this court when the validity of a statute is the primary inquiry. It is not enough that merely the proper construction of the statute is involved.</p> <p>2. In trespass, for breaking the plaintiff’s close and killing his horses, the defendants justified their acts under the statute creating the board of live stock commissioners. The plaintiff replied that the acts of which he complained were not such as are contemplated by that statute, but were acts done in excess of any authority it confers, on which replication issue was joined, and a trial was had, resulting in a judgment for the plaintiff: Held, on appeal from that judgment, by the defendants, that under the issue the validity of the statute was not involved, but, at most, only its construction.</p> <p>3. If the plaintiff had demurred to the plea setting up the statute, or had objected to the introduction of evidence under the statute, and the court had decided against him, and he had excepted to the ruling and assigned cross-errors, the validity of the statute would have been involved on the defendant’s appeal, and the appeal could have been brought directly to this court.</p> <p>4. Practice—to what case objection must be made. A constitutional provision designed solely for the protection of the property rights of the citizen, may be waived by him; and hence if he, at the time, makes no objection to a ruling depriving him of such right, he can not afterward assign such ruling for error.</p> <p>5. Practice in the Supreme Court—disregarding certain errors assigned—cross-errors, when necessary. An appellate court, although proper exceptions have been taken to the rulings of the trial court, and errors are properly assigned, may disregard certain errors, upon the ground that they would have been immaterial had the court properly ruled on other questions; but in such case it is indispensable that cross-errors
Judges: Scholfield
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
8 cases in this archive cite this case.
- People v. AmermanIllinois Supreme Court· 1971-11-30· cited 125×
- Chicago-Sandoval Coal Co. v. Industrial CommissionIllinois Supreme Court· 1922-02-22· cited 20×
- Village of Riverside v. KuhneIllinois Supreme Court· 1947-05-22· cited 13×
- Stearns v. ReidyAppellate Court of Illinois· 1889-05-29· cited 9×
- Grace & Hyde Co. v. SanbornAppellate Court of Illinois· 1906-02-13· cited 8×
- Commissioners of Highways v. Chicago & Northwestern Railway Co.Appellate Court of Illinois· 1889-12-16· cited 2×
- First National Bank v. SandmeyerAppellate Court of Illinois· 1911-10-20· cited 2×
- Murphy v. Martin Oil Co.Appellate Court of Illinois· 1972-04-11· cited 1×
Cites
2 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.