Seventh Circuit· 6/5/1998
Paul J. Hoffman v. McA Inc.
Citations
- 144 F.3d 1117
- 1998 U.S. App. LEXIS 11807
- 77 Fair Empl. Prac. Cas. (BNA) 559
- 1998 WL 297164
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that for summary judgment, Court must assume that any discriminatory intent on the supervisor's part tainted the decisionmaker's decision, making the supervisor's remarks relevant to proving that the decisionmaker's decision was unlawful
- holding that an employer’s call for “fresh legs” in the office “could have been talking about hiring additional personnel, not replacing” the plaintiff and “is too vague for [the court] to read it as inculpating” the defendant
- noting that an employer “could reasonably expect a higher level of professionalism from [a seasoned employee] with less need for supervision than it could expect from less experienced and lower-ranking sales representatives”
- “Standing alone, however, [age-related] statements [not directly related to the employment decision] are insufficient to establish pretext.”
- “[E]ven taking the statement to mean ‘we need a young person in Chicago’ we cannot say that the statement is linked to the decision to fire Hoffman.”
- supervisor’s discriminatory animus tainted decisionmaker since supervisor wrote series of memoranda about plaintiff
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Bauer, Ripple, Kanne
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
39 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Kim Patterson v. Avery Dennison CorporationSeventh Circuit· 2002-02-26· cited 355×
- Martin I. Robin v. Espo Engineering CorporationSeventh Circuit· 2000-01-13· cited 207×
- Gonzalez v. El Dia, Inc.First Circuit· 2002-09-05· cited 191×
- Stephen Fakete v. Aetna, Inc., D/B/A Aetna/us HealthcareThird Circuit· 2002-10-24· cited 173×
- Pens. Plan Guide (Cch) P 23954p Roy A. Jackson and Carlos E. Serment v. E.J. Brach CorporationSeventh Circuit· 1999-05-05· cited 168×
- Schandelmeier-Bartels v. Chicago Park DistrictSeventh Circuit· 2011-02-08· cited 125×
- Senske v. SYBASE, INCORPORATEDSeventh Circuit· 2009-12-03· cited 97×
- James R. Fairchild v. Forma Scientific, Inc. And Life Sciences International, Inc.Seventh Circuit· 1998-06-10· cited 92×
- Tracey Lust v. Sealy, Inc.Seventh Circuit· 2004-09-07· cited 92×
- MacH v. Will County SheriffSeventh Circuit· 2009-09-01· cited 77×
- Hancock v. PotterSeventh Circuit· 2008-06-24· cited 63×
- Richard M. Kadas v. MCI Systemhouse CorporationSeventh Circuit· 2001-06-19· cited 51×
- Elmer Ritter v. Hill 'N Dale Farm, Inc.Seventh Circuit· 2000-11-09· cited 46×
- Sheila Main v. Ozark Health IncEighth Circuit· 2020-05-11· cited 39×
- Ethel Louise Hill v. Lockheed Martin Logistics Management, IncorporatedFourth Circuit· 2003-01-07· cited 11×
- Lust v. Sealy, Inc.W.D. Wisconsin· 2003-08-19· cited 7×
- Archer Daniels Midland Co. v. WhitacreC.D. Illinois· 1999-08-05· cited 6×
- Rayl v. Fort Wayne Community SchoolsN.D. Indiana· 2000-02-10· cited 4×
- Rotec Industries, Inc. v. Mitsubishi Corp.C.D. Illinois· 1999-01-12· cited 4×
- Burns v. Bombela-TobiasAppellate Court of Illinois· 2020-03-27· cited 4×
Cites
20 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc.Supreme Court· 1986-06-25· cited 135,235×
- Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, Administratrix of the Estate of CatrettSupreme Court· 1986-06-25· cited 119,442×
- Matsushita Electric Industrial Co., Ltd. v. Zenith Radio CorporationSupreme Court· 1986-03-26· cited 58,760×
- McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. GreenSupreme Court· 1973-05-14· cited 38,518×
- St. Mary's Honor Center v. HicksSupreme Court· 1993-06-25· cited 8,844×
- Price Waterhouse v. HopkinsSupreme Court· 1989-05-01· cited 3,836×
- John T. Russell v. Acme-Evans Company, Adm Milling Company, and Archer-Daniels-Midland CompanySeventh Circuit· 1995-04-19· cited 500×
- Ralph C. SHAGER, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. UPJOHN COMPANY and Asgrow Seed Company, Defendants-AppelleesSeventh Circuit· 1990-09-17· cited 491×
- Arthur S. ANDERSON, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. BAXTER HEALTHCARE CORP., Defendant-AppelleeSeventh Circuit· 1994-01-11· cited 369×
- Nicholas A. CHIARAMONTE, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. FASHION BED GROUP, INC., a DIVISION OF LEGGETT & PLATT, INC., Defendant-AppelleeSeventh Circuit· 1997-11-04· cited 297×
- Shirley Mills v. First Federal Savings & Loan Association of BelvidereFirst Circuit· 1996-05-07· cited 168×
- Jimmie Huff v. Uarco, Incorporated, William M. Schoolman v. Uarco, Incorporated, and the Trustees of the Uarco Retirement PlanSeventh Circuit· 1997-08-06· cited 131×
- Dolores J. Fuka v. Thomson Consumer ElectronicsSeventh Circuit· 1996-05-06· cited 130×
- Gladys F. WILLIS, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. MARION COUNTY AUDITOR'S OFFICE, Defendant-AppelleeSeventh Circuit· 1997-07-01· cited 125×
- Ronald ROBINSON, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. PPG INDUSTRIES, INC., Defendant-AppelleeSeventh Circuit· 1994-05-04· cited 120×
- Dharam v. BAHL, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. ROYAL INDEMNITY COMPANY and Royal Insurance Company of America, Defendants-AppelleesSeventh Circuit· 1997-05-28· cited 92×
- Linda Thiele, Guardian of the Person and Estate of Craig Thiele v. Norfolk & Western Railway CompanySeventh Circuit· 1995-10-12· cited 71×
- Robert DENISI, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. DOMINICK’S FINER FOODS, INC., Defendant-AppelleeSeventh Circuit· 1996-11-01· cited 69×
- Jo Ann Stopka v. Alliance of American Insurers, Rodger S. Lawson, C. Clarke ImblerSeventh Circuit· 1998-04-01· cited 64×
- Hoffman v. MCA, Inc.N.D. Illinois· 1997-08-01· cited 1×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.