Skip to main content

Orr v. Orr

Citations

  • 34 S.C. 275
  • 13 S.E. 467
  • 1891 S.C. LEXIS 49

Syllabus

<p>1. Evidence — Executor’s Accounts. — In action against an executor for account in which it is sought to charge him with an uncollected asset of his testator, he testified, against objection, that the life tenant told him that testator did not wish the debtor to be sued, and that the life-tenant would never consent to such a suit. Although no ruling was made in the court below on this objection, it must be considered here, as the evidence bears so directly on the question at issue of the executor’s good faith, and while it was incompetent so far as it attempted to declare the wishes of the testator as to the management of the estate, by hearsay and by verbal directions, it was competent so far as the life tenant’s wishes were declared, and relevant to the issue of good faith.</p> <p>2. Executors — Uncollected Asset — Life Tenant. — Where testator devised and bequeathed his entire estate to his widow for life, “to have, to hold, and enjoy during her natural life,” with remainder over, and such estate consisted in part of an unsecured note taken by testator, which the life tenant received into her possession and deterred the executor from suing by her express and earnest objections, and which after her death was worthless, the testimony failing to make it appear that earlier suit would have realized on the note, although others had collected money from the debtor, there is not sufficient to charge the executor with a want of that care and diligence which the law requires in such cases.</p> <p>3. Ibid. — Ibid.-—Ibid.—Would the executor be relieved of all liability to the remaindermen under the terms of this will by surrendering to the possession and control of the life tenant an unsecured chose in action in the form in which the testator had left it ?</p>

Judges: McIver

Read full opinion on CourtListener

Other cases with this name

Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).

This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.