Orr v. Gilman
Citations
- 183 U.S. 278
- 22 S. Ct. 213
- 46 L. Ed. 196
- 1902 U.S. LEXIS 718
Syllabus
<p>The provisions of subdivision 5 of the tax law of the State of New York, which became a law April 16,1897, are not in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution, nor of section 10 of article 1 of the Constitution.</p> <p>The opinion in Carpenter v. Pennsylvania, 17 How. 456, although decided before the adoption of the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution, correctly defines the limits of jurisdiction between the State and the Federal governments, in respect to the control of the estates of decedents, both as they'were regarded before the adoption of the Fourteenth Amendment, and have since been regarded.</p> <p>The holding of the Court of Appeals of New York, that it was the execution of the power of appointment which subjected grantees under it to the transfer tax, is binding upon this court.</p> <p>'The Court of Appeals did not err when it held that a transfer or succession tax, not being a direct tax upon property, but a charge upon a privilege, exercised' or enjoyed-under the laws of thé State, does not, when imposed in cases where the property passing consists of securities exempt by statute, impair the obligation of a contract within the meaning of the Constitution of the United States.</p> <p>The view of the Court of Appeals in this case must be accepted by this court as an accurate statement of the law of the State.</p>
Judges: Shiras, Harlan
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
59 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Chase National Bank v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1929-01-02· cited 497×
- National Life Insurance v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1928-06-04· cited 411×
- Blodgett v. SilbermanSupreme Court· 1928-04-16· cited 249×
- Willcutts v. BunnSupreme Court· 1931-01-05· cited 241×
- Saltonstall v. SaltonstallSupreme Court· 1928-02-20· cited 222×
- Coolidge v. LongSupreme Court· 1931-02-24· cited 183×
- Educational Films Corp. of America v. WardSupreme Court· 1931-01-12· cited 182×
- Colgate v. HarveySupreme Court· 1935-12-16· cited 178×
- Chanler v. KelseySupreme Court· 1907-04-15· cited 117×
- Kentucky Union Co. v. KentuckySupreme Court· 1911-01-03· cited 88×
- Graves v. SchmidlappSupreme Court· 1942-03-30· cited 73×
- Whitney v. State Tax Comm'n of NYSupreme Court· 1940-03-25· cited 68×
- Greiner v. LewellynSupreme Court· 1922-04-10· cited 67×
- Central Hanover Bank & Trust Co. v. KellySupreme Court· 1943-05-03· cited 53×
- Frick's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1923-04-30· cited 42×
- Attorney General v. StoneMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1911-05-19· cited 41×
- Wachovia Bank & Trust Co. v. DoughtonSupreme Court· 1926-11-29· cited 35×
- First Unitarian Church v. County of Los AngelesCalifornia Supreme Court· 1957-04-24· cited 32×
- Estate of NewtonCalifornia Supreme Court· 1950-09-07· cited 32×
- In re StanleySupreme Judicial Court of Maine· 1934-07-27· cited 29×
Cites
7 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Calder v. BullSupreme Court· 1798-08-17· cited 1,860×
- United States v. CruikshankSupreme Court· 1876-03-27· cited 1,277×
- Knowlton v. MooreSupreme Court· 1900-05-14· cited 739×
- Plummer v. ColerSupreme Court· 1900-05-14· cited 196×
- Watson v. MercerSupreme Court· 1834-03-18· cited 155×
- Clarke v. ClarkeSupreme Court· 1900-05-21· cited 119×
- CARPENTER v. Commonwealth of PennsylvaniaSupreme Court· 1855-02-13· cited 66×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.