Ocala Foundry & Machine Works v. Lester
Citations
- 49 Fla. 199
Syllabus
<p>1. The lien upon personal property given by the Revised Statutes of 1892 to a laborer or mechanic who performs labor and furnishes materials for repairing it, does not as between the parties thereto expire at the end of three months from the time the labor was performed or materials furnished, even though the laborer or mechanic retains possession of the property for .that period of time, mor does the latter lose the right to enforce his lien by proceedings at law or in equity, within or subsequent to that period but within one year, even though he retains possession, or shall have retained possession for the full period of three months.</p> <p>2. Three months retention of the possession of personal property by a mechanic who has repaired it, though mentioned as a remedy for enforcing the mechanics lien by section 1743 Revised Statutes of 1892, is .not designed as a full and complete remedy, but merely as a means of exerting moral pressure for inducing or hastening voluntary payment from the debtor. The other remedies given by that section are not inconsistent with the right to retain possession, but are cumulative, and so long as the retention of possession fails to secure payment of the debt, it does not extinguish or discharge the lien, nor preclude resort to other remedies provided.</p> <p>3. The existence of a lien upon personal property does not carry with it the right of possession, if a statute otherwise provides; therefore the lien may exist in favor of a mechanic, consistently with the right of the debtor-to possession of the property, if such is 'the intention of the statute. ’</p> <p>4. Under section 1743 Revised Statutes of 1892, where possession of personal property has been retained by the laborer or mechanic for the period of three months after the lien attached though the lien still continues as between the parties, the right to retain possession as against the consent of the debtor expires, and upon a demand for possession made by him after the
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- “Many authorities hold and this court herein agrees that the true measure of damages [in a replevin action] is the fair, reasonable, ordinary value of the use of the property.’’
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Carter, Cker, Cockrell, Shackleford, Taylor, Whitfield
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
19 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Evans v. KloeppelSupreme Court of Florida· 1916-11-21· cited 31×
- Riddle v. Dean MacHinery Co.Missouri Court of Appeals· 1978-01-30· cited 22×
- Amendments to the Florida Rules of Civil ProcedureSupreme Court of Florida· 2000-10-05· cited 22×
- Butler v. MirabelliDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 1965-10-21· cited 12×
- Eastern Airlines Emp. Fed. Cred. U. v. Yacht Basin, Inc.District Court of Appeal of Florida· 1976-04-30· cited 7×
- FORESIGHT ENTER. v. Leisure Time Prop.District Court of Appeal of Florida· 1985-02-21· cited 6×
- Gregory v. WoodberySupreme Court of Florida· 1907-01-15· cited 6×
- Harwell v. WilderDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 1971-04-21· cited 5×
- Aviation Investments, Inc. v. CameronFifth Circuit· 1965-09-23· cited 5×
- HEG, Inc. v. Bay Bank & Trust Co.District Court of Appeal of Florida· 1991-12-20· cited 3×
- Hart Land & Cattle Co. v. Reeves Steel, Inc.District Court of Appeal of Florida· 1975-01-08· cited 2×
- Associates Commercial Corp. v. RossDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 1985-03-27· cited 2×
- Hendry v. EllisSupreme Court of Florida· 1911-01-15· cited 1×
- Goodbody & Co. v. DodsonDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 1970-11-17· cited 1×
- Aviation Investments, Inc. v. CameronFifth Circuit· 1965-11-10
- Miami Air Conditioning Co. v. RoodDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 1969-05-27
- Conner v. Trans Air Supply Co.District Court of Appeal of Florida· 1983-01-25
- In re Amendment to Florida Rules of Civil Procedure—Final Judgment of Replevin Forms 1.995(a)-(d)Supreme Court of Florida· 1998-10-15
- Campos v. Courtesy Ford, Inc.District Court of Appeal of Florida· 2005-04-27
Cites
13 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- State ex rel. Illinois Cent. R. v. Board of Levee Com'rsSupreme Court of Louisiana· 1902-03-03· cited 68×
- West v. FlemmingIllinois Supreme Court· 1857-04-15· cited 22×
- Murray v. RapleySupreme Court of Arkansas· 1875-11-15· cited 18×
- Younglove v. KnoxSupreme Court of Florida· 1902-06-15· cited 14×
- Pratt v. TudorTexas Supreme Court· 1855-07-01· cited 11×
- Cooper v. LivingstonSupreme Court of Florida· 1883-01-15· cited 11×
- Sebree v. SmithIdaho Supreme Court· 1888-02-25· cited 10×
- Peerless Machine Co. v. GatesSupreme Court of Minnesota· 1895-05-15· cited 9×
- Farrar v. EashIndiana Court of Appeals· 1892-10-12· cited 7×
- Clark v. MartinMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1876-09-09· cited 6×
- Qualy v. JohnsonSupreme Court of Minnesota· 1900-07-10· cited 6×
- Nash v. LarsonSupreme Court of Minnesota· 1900-07-16· cited 6×
- Broadbent v. JohnsonIdaho Supreme Court· 1887-02-14· cited 2×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.