Nougues v. Douglass
Citations
- 7 Cal. 65
Syllabus
<p>The act of April 18, 1856, providing for the erection of a State capítol, at a cost not to exceed $300,000, is unconstitutional and void.</p> <p>The eighth article of the Constitution of this State is an express restriction upon the powers of the Legislature, and there is no power in the judiciary to set it aside, whatever inconvenience may result from a legitimate application of the provision.</p> <p>So far from the necessary and ordinary expenses of the State forming an exception to the restriction, they were evidently among those especially included in it.</p> <p>The power of taxation was given to the Legislature without limit, for all purposes allowed by the Constitution.</p> <p>As to the point raised, that conceding the construction of the Court to be correct, the provision is only advisory, and addressed to the legislative conscience, and not to the judiciary: It seems, that an express restriction upon the powers of the Legislature cannot bo said to be merely advisory.</p> <p>Some of the restrictions upon the powers of the Legislature, are addressed solely to that body, and of which it is the exclusive judge, as the provisions relating to the qualifications, election, and return of its own members.</p> <p>The true rule seems to be this: that when the right to determine the extent and effect of the restriction is either expressly, or by necessary implication, confided to the Legislature, then the judiciary has no right to interfere with the legislative construction.</p> <p>But in all other cases of restriction, it is the right and duty of the Supreme Court to decide the effect and extent of the restriction in the last resort, and the question, whether that right is vested in the Legislature or in the judiciary, must be equally decided by the Supreme Court. a</p> <p>The Constitution is itself a law, and must be construed by some one. The judiciary, from the very nature of its powers, and the means given it by the Constitution, must possess the right to constr
Judges: Burnett, Murray
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
26 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Raven v. DeukmejianCalifornia Supreme Court· 1990-12-24· cited 273×
- Legislature v. EuCalifornia Supreme Court· 1991-10-10· cited 222×
- California Redevelopment Ass'n v. MatosantosCalifornia Supreme Court· 2011-12-29· cited 196×
- Kopp v. Fair Political Practices CommissionCalifornia Supreme Court· 1995-11-30· cited 155×
- Amwest Surety Insurance v. WilsonCalifornia Supreme Court· 1995-12-14· cited 126×
- People ex rel. McCauley & Tevis v. BrooksCalifornia Supreme Court· 1860-07-01· cited 112×
- Hotel Employees & Restaurant Employees International Union v. DavisCalifornia Supreme Court· 1999-08-23· cited 93×
- People v. BunnCalifornia Supreme Court· 2002-01-10· cited 89×
- Delaney v. LoweryCalifornia Supreme Court· 1944-12-28· cited 78×
- Schabarum v. California LegislatureCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1998-01-14· cited 77×
- Strauss v. HortonCalifornia Supreme Court· 2009-06-17· cited 65×
- Koppikus v. State Capitol Comm'rsCalifornia Supreme Court· 1860-07-01· cited 62×
- State ex rel. University of Utah v. CandlandUtah Supreme Court· 1909-09-22· cited 51×
- Miller v. DunnCalifornia Supreme Court· 1887-06-06· cited 46×
- Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn. v. PadillaCalifornia Supreme Court· 2016-01-04· cited 38×
- Bess v. ParkCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1955-03-30· cited 33×
- City of Oakland v. BrockCalifornia Supreme Court· 1937-04-27· cited 30×
- State Budget Commission v. LebusCourt of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976)· 1932-06-24· cited 24×
- Foothill Federal Credit Union v. Superior CourtCalifornia Court of Appeal· 2007-09-24· cited 17×
- Olson v. CoryCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1982-06-25· cited 14×
Cites
1 case in this archive is cited by this case.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.