Skip to main content

Murphy v. Commonwealth

Citations

  • 23 Va. 960

Syllabus

<p>1. The act of March 30th, 1871, Sess. acts. 1870-71, p. 332, does not. give justices of the peace jurisdiction to try a case of felony; and the conviction and punishment of a party by a justice for an assault and battery, will not bar a prosecution for wounding with intent to lciH, by the same act for which he was punished by the justice.</p> <p>2. If the accused has been indicted and convicted for a mere assault and battery in the county court having jurisdiction of such of-fence generally, the conviction will not be a bar to an indictment for a felony, in the perpetration qf which the assault and battery was committed.</p> <p>3. On a trial for an assault with intent to kill, the witness upon whom the assault was alleged to have been made, was asked if he did not teH his wife that the prisoner acted only in his own defence. The answer to the question may tend to criminate himself, and the testimony is inadmissible. 2d: It required him to state a communication supposed to have been made by- him to his wife; which, if made, was a confidential communication, and which he was not bound to disclose.</p> <p>t. A question is put to the witness which he answers, and which relates to a collateral matter not connected with the subject of the prosecution. His answer to that question was conclusive, and could not be contradicted.</p> <p>;. In this case, after the witness was asked the question^whether he. did not state to his wife that the defendant had acted only in his own defence, and he had answered the question denying that he had done so, the wife of the witness was introduced to prove the statement was made to her. She is not a competent ■ witness to prove it, though at the time it was alleged to have been made, they were living apart from each other; but not divorced.</p> <p>6. A man is taken to intend that which he does, or which is the natural and necessary consequence of his own act. Therefore, if the prisoner wounded the prosecutor, by the deliberate use of an i

Judges: Moncure

Read full opinion on CourtListener

Other cases with this name

Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).

This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.