Morris v. Bean
Citations
- 146 F. 423
- 1906 U.S. App. LEXIS 4115
Syllabus
<p>1. Courts — United States Courts — Jurisdiction—Amount in Controversy.</p> <p>In a suit concerning water rights the thing in controversy is the right to the use of the water, and where that exceeds in value 82,000, exclusive of interest and costs, a Circuit Court of the United States has jurisdiction.</p> <p>2. Water and Water Courses — Actions to Protect Rights — Right of Action — Interstate Streams — I uiusdiction.</p> <p>A citizen of one state may maintain a suit in a Circuit Court of the United States in another state to enjoin the unlawful diversion of water in the state where the suit is brought, which prevents its flowing- to his lands in the state of his, residence.</p> <p>3. Same — Appropriation of Water Eights.</p> <p>The complainant, a citizen and resident of Wyoming, instituted a suit in the Circuit Court of the United States -for the District of Montana to enjoin the defendants, residents and citizens of that state, from diverting water from a stream rising in Montana and flowing into Wyoming. Held, that'defendants could not justify their diversion of water in Montana in hostility to the rights of the complainant in Wyoming upon the ground that the laws of Montana authorize its citizens to appropriate water within the state. Held further, that the fact that the stream has its source in Montana, and from thence flows into Wyoming, does not affect the right to appropriate, hut that the general doctrine of priority governs regardless of state lines.</p> <p>4. Same — Definition-.</p> <p>An appropriation consists of the diversion of water and its application to some beneficial use. In the absence of any statute, if the work is prosecuted with reasonable diligence, the right of the appropriate»: relates to the beginning of the work.</p> <p>5. Same — Kecording—Notice.</p> <p>Where one approiiriates under a statute, the recording of the claim- is constructive notice, but such statutes do not preclude the taking of water for beneficial uses by methods other t
Judges: Whitson
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
15 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Wyoming v. ColoradoSupreme Court· 1922-06-05· cited 115×
- Emery v. EmeryMontana Supreme Court· 1948-12-01· cited 52×
- Reno v. RichardsIdaho Supreme Court· 1918-12-26· cited 33×
- San Antonio River Authority v. LewisTexas Supreme Court· 1962-11-28· cited 23×
- Scott v. McTiernanWyoming Supreme Court· 1999-03-22· cited 14×
- Farmers Dev. Co. v. Rayado L. & I. Co.New Mexico Supreme Court· 1923-01-15· cited 12×
- Howell v. BentMontana Supreme Court· 1913-11-29· cited 9×
- Weiland v. Pioneer Irr. Co.Eighth Circuit· 1916-11-18· cited 8×
- L. Mini Estate Co. v. WalshCalifornia Supreme Court· 1935-08-29· cited 6×
- Joint Board Of Control Of The Flathead, Mission And Jocko Irrigation Districts v. United StatesNinth Circuit· 1987-11-17· cited 4×
- State v. AchepohlWashington Supreme Court· 1926-04-27· cited 4×
- Loyning v. LoyningNinth Circuit· 1949-01-03· cited 3×
- Barry v. Merickel Holding Corp.Nevada Supreme Court· 1940-12-18· cited 3×
- Loyning v. RankinMontana Supreme Court· 1946-01-08· cited 2×
- United States v. Ash Sheep Co.Ninth Circuit· 1915-03-08· cited 2×
Cites
27 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Galliher v. CadwellSupreme Court· 1892-05-16· cited 308×
- Cherokee Nation v. Southern Kansas Railway Co.Supreme Court· 1890-05-19· cited 284×
- Lux v. HagginCalifornia Supreme Court· 1886-04-26· cited 265×
- Newhall v. SangerSupreme Court· 1876-05-18· cited 141×
- Elgin v. MarshallSupreme Court· 1883-01-18· cited 124×
- Broder v. Water Co.Supreme Court· 1879-11-24· cited 109×
- Farm Investment Co. v. CarpenterWyoming Supreme Court· 1900-05-26· cited 87×
- Rigney v. Tacoma Light & Water Co.Washington Supreme Court· 1894-10-15· cited 52×
- Benton v. JohncoxWashington Supreme Court· 1897-07-02· cited 47×
- Vansickle v. HainesNevada Supreme Court· 1872-01-15· cited 44×
- Willey v. DeckerWyoming Supreme Court· 1903-08-03· cited 43×
- De Necochea v. CurtisCalifornia Supreme Court· 1889-09-04· cited 42×
- Stinson v. DousmanSupreme Court· 1858-05-10· cited 31×
- Gould v. EatonCalifornia Supreme Court· 1897-07-09· cited 25×
- Moyer v. PrestonWyoming Supreme Court· 1896-04-27· cited 24×
- Howell v. JohnsonU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Montana· 1898-08-20· cited 22×
- Boyce v. CupperOregon Supreme Court· 1900-07-02· cited 17×
- Huston v. BybeeOregon Supreme Court· 1888-12-19· cited 16×
- Watterson v. SaldunbehereCalifornia Supreme Court· 1894-01-17· cited 11×
- Anderson v. BassmanU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Northern California· 1905-08-12· cited 11×
Other cases named Morris v. Bean
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.