Montoya v. Ortiz
Citations
- 24 N.M. 616
Syllabus
<p>SYLLABUS BY THE COURT.</p> <p>1. The rule announced in the case of Carabajal v. Lucero, 22 N. M. 30, 158 Pac. 1088, that, in the absence of a showing of fraud on the part of election officers sufficient to invalidate the returns and to cast discredit upon the ballots, preserved as required by law, the individual voters cannot be permitted to testify as to the candidates for whom they voted at an election, has no application to the question of the right of an illegal voter to testify as to the persons for whom he voted at an election. P. 621</p> <p>2. In the case of illegal voters, it is universally recognized that the right to examine the voters in such a case is in af-firmance and vindication of the essential principle of the elective system that the will of the majority of the qualified voters shall determine the right to an elective office, and the testimony of the voter, after it has been shown that he voted illegally, is competent and should be received by the court for what it is worth. P. 622</p> <p>3. An illegal voter cannot be required to testify in the first instance as to whether he did in fact vote, if he claims his constitutional privilege against self-incrimination, but, if it is proven by other evidence that he did vote, he may then be compelled to testify for whom he voted. P. 622</p> <p>4. Circumstantial evidence is competent to prove the fact for whom an illegal voter voted,-and, where the facts and circumstances in evidence clearly establish for whom he voted, the court is justified in finding the ultimate fact. P. 623</p> <p>5. Circumstantial evidence may be resorted to where it does not appear from the testimony of the voter for whom he voted. p. 623</p> <p>6. Where it is shown that ballot boxes have been in the custody of parties not entitled thereto, the burden rests upon the contestant to show that during such time the ballot boxes were not tampered with. p. 624</p> <p>7. Departure from the strict letter of the statute ■ as to the preserva
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- appellate court vested with broad discretion to remand cade for a new trial or other proceedings, and such will be ordered when it appears that justice so requires
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Hanna, Paekee, Roberts
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
9 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Gerety v. DemersNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1978-12-13· cited 79×
- Trujillo v. City of AlbuquerqueNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1990-10-03· cited 64×
- Kiehne v. AtwoodNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1979-12-05· cited 24×
- Orchard v. Board of Com'rs of Sierra CountyNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1938-02-01· cited 12×
- Reese v. DempseyNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1944-11-14· cited 10×
- Trujillo v. TrujilloNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1948-09-07· cited 8×
- Darr v. Village of TularosaNew Mexico Court of Appeals· 1998-06-10· cited 7×
- Telles v. CarterNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1953-11-03· cited 6×
- Willis v. CrumblySupreme Court of Arkansas· 2007-11-15· cited 6×
Cites
2 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Other cases named Montoya v. Ortiz
3 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.