Mobile Transportation Co. v. Mobile
Citations
- 187 U.S. 479
- 23 S. Ct. 170
- 47 L. Ed. 266
- 1903 U.S. LEXIS 1667
Syllabus
<p>1. A motion to dismiss for want of a Federal question .cannot be sustained when the title involved depends upon a Spanish grant claimed to have been perfected under the treaty of 1819 with Spain, and a patent of the United States in alleged confirmation of such claim.</p> <p>2. It has been conclusively settled by this court that the State of Alabama, when admitted to the Union, hecaine entitled to the soil under the navigable waters below high water mark within the limits of the State, not previously granted. Pollard's Lessee v. Hagan, 3 How. 212.</p> <p>The act of the legislature of Alabama of January 31,1867, conveying to the city of Mobile the shore and soil under Mobile River is not unconstitutional as impairing vested rights of owners of grants bordering on Mobile River, as the rule in Alabama that a grant by the United States of lands bordering on a navigable river includes the shore or bank of such river and extends to the water line at low 'water, does not relate to land bordering on tidal streams.</p> <p>. As the State held the lands under water below high water mark as trustee for the public it had the right to devolve the trust upon the city of Mobile. ■■</p> <p>3.-All the land below high water mark having passed to Alabama on her admission to the Union in 1819, there was nothing left upon which a patent of the United States dated in 1836, could operate, and-the person claiming to hpld land below high water mark under said patent has no vested interest in such land, which would require compensation or proceedings in eminent domain on the part of the State to take such lands.</p> <p>There is a difference between the legislature of a State granting land beneath navigable waters of the State, and below high water mark, to a private railroad corporation and granting, it to a municipal corporation Whose mayor; aldermen and common council are created and declared trustees to hold, possess, direct,, control and manage the shore and soil granted in such manner
Judges: Brown
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
16 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Borax Consolidated, Ltd. v. Los AngelesSupreme Court· 1935-11-11· cited 194×
- Coastal Petroleum v. American CyanamidSupreme Court of Florida· 1986-05-15· cited 35×
- United States v. TurnerFifth Circuit· 1949-06-10· cited 27×
- Commonwealth v. City of Newport NewsSupreme Court of Virginia· 1932-06-16· cited 23×
- Hill v. NewellWashington Supreme Court· 1915-07-07· cited 21×
- State ex rel. Buford v. City of TampaSupreme Court of Florida· 1924-09-09· cited 16×
- Mobile Transportation Co. v. City of MobileSupreme Court· 1905-12-11· cited 15×
- Sweat v. CommonwealthSupreme Court of Virginia· 1929-06-13· cited 11×
- Price v. State Of HawaiiNinth Circuit· 1990-12-26· cited 10×
- Percy Summer Club v. AstleFirst Circuit· 1908-05-20· cited 8×
- Reid v. STATE, ETC.Supreme Court of Alabama· 1979-06-29· cited 7×
- City of Mobile v. Sullivan Timber Co.Fifth Circuit· 1904-04-08· cited 7×
- Cove Properties, Inc. v. Walter Trent Marina, Inc.Court of Civil Appeals of Alabama· 1999-04-09· cited 3×
- McKnight v. BroedellE.D. Michigan· 1962-12-13· cited 2×
- City of Oakwood v. Hartford Accident & Indemnity Co.Sixth Circuit· 1936-02-14· cited 2×
- State ex rel. Gallion v. ArgiroSupreme Court of Alabama· 1961-11-02
Cites
7 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Hardin v. JordanSupreme Court· 1891-05-11· cited 381×
- Barney v. KeokukSupreme Court· 1877-04-23· cited 297×
- Packer v. BirdSupreme Court· 1891-01-19· cited 144×
- Central Land Co. v. LaidleySupreme Court· 1895-06-03· cited 88×
- John Goodtitle v. Gaius KibbeSupreme Court· 1850-05-28· cited 68×
- Bullock v. WilsonSupreme Court of Alabama· 1835-06-15· cited 23×
- Doe Ex Dem. Hallett v. BeebeSupreme Court· 1852-02-11· cited 12×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.