Third Circuit· 3/11/1988
Metzger v. Osbeck
Citations
- 841 F.2d 518
- 1988 U.S. App. LEXIS 3090
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that excessive corporal punishment violates substantive due process
- student sustained a broken nose, fractured teeth, lacerations, and other injuries requiring hospitalization
- “[W]e cannot permit a summary judgment to be granted to a defendant who, by an intentional act, may have caused serious harm simply because he says he did not intend the harm.”
- school official’s conduct consisting of grabbing student in chokehold and causing student to lose consciousness and fall to the pavement resulting in student breaking his nose and fracturing teeth analyzed under corporal punishment framework
- “a decision to discipline a student, if accomplished through excessive force and appreciable physical pain, may constitute an invasion of the child’s Fifth Amendment liberty interest in personal security and a violation of substantive due process prohibited by the Fourteenth Amendment”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Cited by
28 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Moore v. Willis Independent School DistrictFifth Circuit· 2000-12-01· cited 233×
- Fagan v. City of VinelandThird Circuit· 1994-04-29· cited 169×
- Heather Wallace, a Minor, by Her Mother and Next Friend, Phyllis Wallace v. The Batavia School District 101, a Municipal Corporation, and James CliffeSeventh Circuit· 1995-10-19· cited 105×
- P.B. v. KochNinth Circuit· 1996-09-27· cited 77×
- Tw Ex Rel. Wilson v. School Bd., Seminole, Fla.Eleventh Circuit· 2010-06-29· cited 72×
- Peterson v. BakerEleventh Circuit· 2007-10-25· cited 34×
- O. v. Ft Bend Indep Sch DistFifth Circuit· 2021-06-17· cited 34×
- United States v. Premises Known As 717 South Woodward Street, Allentown, PennsylvaniaSecond Circuit· 1993-08-20· cited 33×
- Langer, Terry, M.D. And Langer, Joan v. Monarch Life Insurance Company, and Presbyterian-University of Pennsylvania Medical CenterThird Circuit· 1989-07-06· cited 24×
- Preschooler II v. Clark County School Board of TrusteesNinth Circuit· 2007-03-20· cited 20×
- Kurilla v. CallahanM.D. Pennsylvania· 1999-09-30· cited 19×
- S.M. v. Lakeland School DistrictM.D. Pennsylvania· 2001-06-26· cited 18×
- Jones v. WitinskiM.D. Pennsylvania· 1996-06-28· cited 16×
- Brown Ex Rel. Brown v. RamseyE.D. Virginia· 2000-11-21· cited 16×
- Meeker v. EdmundsonFourth Circuit· 2005-07-13· cited 16×
- Johnson v. Newburgh Enlarged School DistrictSecond Circuit· 2001-01-31· cited 13×
- Dockery v. BarnettS.D. New York· 2001-09-19· cited 12×
- United States v. Premises Known as 717 South Woodard StreetE.D. Pennsylvania· 1992-10-05· cited 10×
- Thomas Englert D/B/A Northeast Electrical Inspection Agency v. City of McKeesport and Middle Department Inspection AgencyThird Circuit· 1989-04-20· cited 9×
- Jorden v. National Guard BureauThird Circuit· 1989-06-06· cited 9×
Cites
23 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc.Supreme Court· 1986-06-25· cited 135,235×
- Monell v. New York City Dept. of Social Servs.Supreme Court· 1978-06-06· cited 41,449×
- Daniels v. WilliamsSupreme Court· 1986-01-21· cited 7,676×
- Ingraham v. WrightSupreme Court· 1977-04-19· cited 2,975×
- Youngberg v. Romeo Ex Rel. RomeoSupreme Court· 1982-06-18· cited 2,433×
- Davidson v. CannonSupreme Court· 1986-01-21· cited 1,806×
- Johnson v. GlickSecond Circuit· 1973-06-29· cited 1,567×
- Anthony J. Chipollini v. Spencer Gifts, Inc., a Delaware Corporation. Appeal of Anthony J. ChipolliniThird Circuit· 1987-03-19· cited 505×
- Colburn v. Upper Darby TownshipThird Circuit· 1988-01-26· cited 283×
- Tennessee Valley Authority v. Alco Standard Corp.Supreme Court· 1987-09-09· cited 264×
- City of Springfield v. KibbeSupreme Court· 1987-04-27· cited 262×
- Hall v. TawneyFourth Circuit· 1980-05-09· cited 224×
- Tigg Corporation v. Dow Corning CorporationThird Circuit· 1987-06-15· cited 191×
- Perales v. KriegerSupreme Court· 1988-01-11· cited 116×
- William SORBA, Appellant, v. PENNSYLVANIA DRILLING COMPANY, INC.Third Circuit· 1987-06-18· cited 103×
- Lois Thurston Kibbe, Administrator of the Estate of Clinton Thurston v. City of SpringfieldFirst Circuit· 1985-11-27· cited 91×
- Unnamed caseFifth Circuit· 1974-07-29· cited 88×
- Rhodes v. RobinsonThird Circuit· 1979-12-28· cited 85×
- Gary W. Justice v. John W. Dennis, Individually and in His Official Capacity as North Carolina State Highway PatrolmanFourth Circuit· 1987-11-25· cited 59×
- Dennis Ray Kidd v. Robert O'Neil Mike Lomonaco Fairfax County Police Dept.Fourth Circuit· 1985-09-23· cited 44×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.