Mencke v. Cargo of Java Sugar
Citations
- 187 U.S. 248
- 23 S. Ct. 86
- 47 L. Ed. 163
- 1902 U.S. LEXIS 812
Syllabus
<p>Where the charter party of a vessel bound with a cargo of sugar from Java, to a port in the United States provides that the vessel should discharge at New York, Boston, Philadelphia or Baltimore “ or so near the port of discharge as she may safely get and deliver the same, always afloat, in a customary place, and manner, in such dock, as directed by charterers, agreeably to bills of lading,” and also provides “all goods to be brought to and taken from alongside of the ship always afloat at said charterers’ risk and expense, who may direct the same at the most convenient anchorage; lighterage, if any, to reach the port of destination, or deliver the cargo at port of destination, remains for account of receivers, any custom of the port to the contrary notwithstanding,” and the vessel has three steel masts built up solidly from the bottom to the top and so riveted there is no way of taking them down and the mainmast requires one hundred and forty-five feet of clear space to pass under any obstruction, which is more than the height at dead low water of the Brooklyn Bridge over the East Biver, charterers have no right to order the vessel to discharge at a dock above the Brooklyn Bridge; and if the vessel discharges by lighterage from the most convenient place below the bridge, the charterers must pay the expense of lighterage from the vessel to the dock. Under the above conditions it is not a just exercise of the right given to the charterers by the charter party to select a dock in getting to which the vessel could not always be afloat or to which she could not safely get.</p> <p>Under such circumstances the vessel is not obliged to sail around Long Island and thus reach the dock above the bridge by coming through Long Island Sound and Hell Gate.</p>
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- requiring the charterer to pay lighterage expenses where vessel discharged at a location other than the chosen berth
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Shiras
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
8 cases in this archive cite this case.
- CITGO Asphalt Refining Co. v. Frescati Shipping Co.Supreme Court· 2020-03-30· cited 54×
- United States v. Citgo Asphalt Refining CompanyThird Circuit· 2013-05-16· cited 36×
- Olsen v. United States Shipping Co.Second Circuit· 1914-03-17· cited 22×
- Yone Suzuki & Co. v. Central Argentine Ry. Ltd.S.D. New York· 1927-03-04· cited 7×
- Crisp v. United States & Australasia S. S. Co.S.D. New York· 1903-06-24· cited 7×
- United States v. Atlantic Refining Co.Second Circuit· 1930-05-05· cited 5×
- Tweedie Trading Co. v. New York & Boston Dyewood Co.Second Circuit· 1903-12-23· cited 3×
- United States v. Atlantic Refining Co.S.D. New York· 1929-05-08· cited 1×
Cites
1 case in this archive is cited by this case.
Other cases named Mencke v. Cargo of Java Sugar
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.