Means v. State
Citations
- 10 Tex. Ct. App. 16
Syllabus
<p>1. Mesne Process on Change of Venue.—The Revised Code of Procedure, art. 591, provides that all witnesses already under recognizance or served with process shall be thereby bound, on a change of venue, to appear before the court to which the cause is transferred. New process is not necessary.</p> <p>2. Continuance —Evidence.—In a trial for murder the defense asked a continuance in order to obtain proof that other persons besides the defendant had motives and opportunities to have killed the deceased. The inculpatory evidence not being purely circumstantial, it is held that the proposed proof was irrelevant and immaterial, and that the refusal of the continuance was not error.</p> <p>3. Murder—Declarations as Res Gestas.—The State was allowed, over objection, to prove that the deceased, while sitting in a church and after gazing out of a window, told a companion that the accused was outside and fixing to kill him (the deceased), and immediately stepped to the door, where he was fired upon and instantly killed. Held, that the declaration was res gestee, and was properly admitted in evidence.</p> <p>á. Charge of the Court.—An instruction to the effect that the jury should reconcile conflicts in the evidence, if practicable to do so, and, if not, should give credence to the witnesses they deem most entitled to belief, is superfluous,but not ostensibly on the weight of evidence or otherwise violative of the Code of Procedure.</p> <p>5. Alibi—Reasonable Doubt.— In a murder case the defense was an alibi, and the defendant’s proof was to the effect that, at the time of the homicide, he was with his brother at a ranche several hundred yards distant. Besides charging the reasonable doubt on the entire case and on the general question of the defendant’s presence at the place and time of the homicide, the charge applied it specifically to the defendant’s proof. Held, that this did not restrict the scope of the defense of alibi.</p>
Judges: White
Read full opinion on CourtListenerSourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.