Martin v. D. B. Martin Co.
Citations
- 10 Del. Ch. 211
- 102 A. 373
- 1913 Del. Ch. LEXIS 5
Syllabus
<p>A court of equity may disregard legal fictions, in order to prevent fraud or obviate its effect.</p> <p>The fact that one person owns all the stock in a corporation does not merge his identity with that of the corporation.</p> <p>The fiction of a legal corporate entity will be ignored, when used to shield fraudulent or illegal acts.</p> <p>Notwithstanding the distinct legal entities of two corporations, persons who are directors and agents in each of two corporations 'cannot represent both in a transaction in which the interests of the two are opposed;</p> <p>Defendant holding corporation, in which complainants are stockholders, owns the stock of seven of eight other corporations engaged in the same business, and finances them, and all of the directors of four of such companies are also directors of defendant corporation, while a majority of the directors of the others are directors of defendant, and the president of defendant is also president of seven of such other corporations. Held, in a proceeding to compel defendant to produce the books of the various companies, for discovering whether defendant is fraudulently mismanaging its corporate affairs, that the subsidiary corporations will be regarded by a court of equity as mere instrumentalities of defendant, and it will be compelled to produce the books of such companies, for discovery, as well as its own.</p> <p>If the documents, the production of which is sought to be compelled by compulsory process, contain matters relevant to the issues, a denial that the documents will show the truth of the issues will not prevent an order for their production.</p>
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- stating that corporate fiction will \never [be] resorted to when it would work an injury to any one [sic]\
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Cited by
25 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- NetJets Aviation, Inc. v. LHC COMMUNICATIONS, LLCSecond Circuit· 2008-08-08· cited 270×
- Pauley Petroleum Inc. v. Continental Oil CompanySupreme Court of Delaware· 1968-01-24· cited 101×
- Overfield v. Pennroad CorporationThird Circuit· 1944-12-28· cited 91×
- Rosenthal v. Burry Biscuit Corp.Court of Chancery of Delaware· 1948-06-16· cited 91×
- Skoglund v. Ormand Industries, Inc.Court of Chancery of Delaware· 1976-12-03· cited 60×
- Bird v. Wilmington Society of the Fine ArtsSupreme Court of Delaware· 1945-05-28· cited 58×
- S. Solomont & Sons Trust, Inc. v. New England Theatres Operating Corp.Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1950-06-07· cited 55×
- Faulkner v. Kornman (In Re Heritage Organization, L.L.C.)N.D. Texas· 2009-05-11· cited 37×
- Scott-Douglas Corp. v. Greyhound Corp.Superior Court of Delaware· 1973-02-23· cited 34×
- Buechner v. Farbenfabriken Bayer AktiengesellschaftCourt of Chancery of Delaware· 1959-10-15· cited 32×
- Farmers State Bank v. HaunWyoming Supreme Court· 1924-01-08· cited 32×
- Alberto v. Diversified Group, Inc.Fifth Circuit· 1995-06-21· cited 29×
- Pauley Petroleum, Inc. v. Continental Oil Co.Court of Chancery of Delaware· 1967-06-23· cited 25×
- Equitable Trust Co. v. GallagherSupreme Court of Delaware· 1953-10-02· cited 21×
- Blaustein v. Pan American Petroleum & Transport Co.New York Supreme Court· 1940-06-08· cited 17×
- John Julian Construction Co. v. Monarch Builders, Inc.Superior Court of Delaware· 1973-04-12· cited 15×
- Bona Fide Demolition & Recovery, LLC v. Crosby Construction Co. of Louisiana, Inc.E.D. Louisiana· 2010-02-01· cited 15×
- Danziger v. LuseOhio Supreme Court· 2004-10-13· cited 13×
- Buechner v. Farbenfabriken Bayer AktiengesellSupreme Court of Delaware· 1959-10-15· cited 9×
- Terry Apartments Associates v. Associated-East Mortgage Co.Court of Chancery of Delaware· 1977-01-31· cited 6×
Cites
6 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- United States v. Milwaukee Refrigerator Transit Co.U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Eastern Wisconsin· 1905-12-28· cited 118×
- In re Rieger, Kapner & AltmarkS.D. Ohio· 1907-11-04· cited 62×
- Exchange Bank v. Macon Construction Co.Supreme Court of Georgia· 1895-10-05· cited 42×
- Commonwealth v. Monongahela Bridge Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1906-06-27· cited 41×
- Regester v. DodgeU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Eastern New York· 1881-02-16· cited 9×
- In re HorganS.D. New York· 1899-10-05· cited 4×
Other cases named Martin v. D. B. Martin Co.
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.