Eighth Circuit· 8/3/2007
Makatengkeng v. Gonzales
Citations
- 495 F.3d 876
- 2007 U.S. App. LEXIS 18486
- 2007 WL 2214486
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that placement in labor camp, death threats, beating, and firing bullets into home fall within the definition of persecution
- holding that to find past persecution petitioner must present evidence of harassment or hardship that rises to the level of persecution, which -2- includes the infliction or threat of death, torture, or injury to one’s person or freedom on account of a statutory ground
- noting that this court has generally “continued to require a showing that allegations of economic hardship threaten the petitioner’s life or freedom in order to rise to the level of persecution”
- doubting whether the medical condition of albinism qualifies as a particular social group
- upholding BIA’s decision because there -9- was no evidence in the record that the Indonesian government was unable or unwilling to control those harassing the applicant
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Loken, Melloy, Schiltz
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
24 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- S-E-GBoard of Immigration Appeals· 2008-07-01· cited 271×
- Davila-Mejia v. MukaseyEighth Circuit· 2008-07-07· cited 89×
- Rosa Gutierrez v. Eric H. Holder, Jr.Eighth Circuit· 2013-04-22· cited 67×
- Julio Matul-Hernandez v. Eric H. Holder, Jr.Eighth Circuit· 2012-07-17· cited 48×
- Ngengwe v. MukaseyEighth Circuit· 2008-09-18· cited 43×
- Malonga v. HolderEighth Circuit· 2010-09-14· cited 32×
- Al Yatim v. MukaseyEighth Circuit· 2008-07-03· cited 30×
- Uli v. MukaseyEighth Circuit· 2008-07-18· cited 27×
- Manani v. FilipEighth Circuit· 2009-01-28· cited 26×
- Beck v. MukaseyEighth Circuit· 2008-05-28· cited 16×
- Xiu Ling Chen v. Eric H. Holder, Jr.Eighth Circuit· 2014-05-13· cited 14×
- Primitivo Alavez-Hernandez v. Eric H. Holder, Jr.Eighth Circuit· 2013-05-08· cited 13×
- Ninoska Lopez-Amador v. Eric H. Holder Jr.Eighth Circuit· 2011-08-15· cited 8×
- Turangan v. MukaseySeventh Circuit· 2009-01-15· cited 1×
- United States v. VillarrealD. Nebraska· 2008-12-30
- Aureo Sergio Ixtlilco-Morales v. Peter D. KeislerEighth Circuit· 2007-11-02
- Istvan Beck v. Michael B. MukaseyEighth Circuit· 2008-05-28
- Anita Uli v. Michael B. MukaseyEighth Circuit· 2008-07-18
- Mamerto Davila-Mejia v. Michael B. MukaseyEighth Circuit· 2008-07-07
- Nasri G. Al Yatim v. Peter D. KeislerEighth Circuit· 2008-07-03
Cites
28 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Immigration & Naturalization Service v. Elias-ZacariasSupreme Court· 1992-01-22· cited 8,324×
- Giuli Ivanishvili v. United States Department of Justice & Attorney General GonzalesSecond Circuit· 2006-01-05· cited 815×
- Zhen Hua Li v. Attorney General of the United States Immigration & Naturalization ServiceThird Circuit· 2005-03-10· cited 434×
- T-ZBoard of Immigration Appeals· 2007-07-01· cited 236×
- Djordje Kovac v. Immigration and Naturalization Service, John P. Boyd, District Director, Seattle, WashingtonNinth Circuit· 1969-01-29· cited 203×
- Wolde Amanuel Feleke v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceEighth Circuit· 1997-07-01· cited 171×
- Azar Safaie v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceEighth Circuit· 1994-07-13· cited 115×
- Jacob Eta-Ndu Catherine Eta-Ndu Danielle Eta-Ndu and Gwladys Eta-Ndu v. Alberto Gonzales, Attorney General of the United States of AmericaEighth Circuit· 2005-06-23· cited 107×
- Sandra Lorena Menjivar v. Alberto Gonzales, Attorney General of the United States of America, 1Eighth Circuit· 2005-07-29· cited 103×
- Syed Kashif Akhtar v. Alberto Gonzales, Attorney GeneralSixth Circuit· 2005-04-29· cited 93×
- Ngwando Zele Nyonzele v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceEighth Circuit· 1996-05-14· cited 84×
- Gabriel Setiadi v. Alberto R. Gonzales, 1 Attorney General of the United States of AmericaEighth Circuit· 2006-02-03· cited 81×
- O-Z- & I-ZBoard of Immigration Appeals· 1998-07-01· cited 81×
- Volodymyr Fisher Irina Nikolaeva v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceEighth Circuit· 2002-05-28· cited 68×
- Yasmin A. Shoaira Hesham Gawdat Tobar v. John Ashcroft, Attorney General of the United States of AmericaEighth Circuit· 2004-09-14· cited 59×
- Yacouba Berte v. John AshcroftEighth Circuit· 2005-02-04· cited 46×
- Sherneth Marcia Raffington v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceEighth Circuit· 2003-08-26· cited 42×
- Marina Koval and Valeriy Vagil v. Alberto R. Gonzales, United States Attorney GeneralSeventh Circuit· 2005-08-16· cited 42×
- Viktor Valioukevitch v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceEighth Circuit· 2001-05-25· cited 40×
- Homi J. Minwalla v. Immigration & Naturalization ServiceEighth Circuit· 1983-05-05· cited 38×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.