Lovato v. New Mexico
Citations
- 242 U.S. 199
- 37 S. Ct. 107
- 61 L. Ed. 244
- 1916 U.S. LEXIS 1512
Syllabus
<p>In a criminal case tried in a District Court of a Territory and coming here by way of the Supreme Court of the State into which the Territory was afterwards converted, defenses based on the Fifth and Sixth Amendments (in part not raised until the case reached the latter court) are within this court’s jurisdiction to consider.</p> <p>Quaere, Whether under the Constitution a defense of former jeopardy is waived if not made before the prosecution has introduced its evidence in chief?</p> <p>Defendant was arraigned and pleaded not guilty to an indictment for murder; on a day subsequent, without withdrawing the plea, he demurred to the indictment as not charging an offense. The demurrer being overruled, both sides being ready for trial, a jury was duly impanelled and sworn and the witnesses for both sides called and sworn, but on motion of the prosecuting officer the court dismissed the jury and directed that the defendant be arraigned anew. This was done forthwith, the accused pleaded not guilty again, and both sides being ready, the same jury was sworn once more and the trial proceeded to a conviction.</p> <p>Held. (1) Not double jeopardy.</p> <p>(2) Due process and the right to á jury, under the Fifth and Sixth Amendments respectively, did not require that a new jury be impanelled after the second arraignment and plea.</p> <p>(3) Under the circumstances, dismissing the jury to allow of the second arraignment and plea, whether a necessary formality or not, was clearly permissible.</p>
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding trial judge acted within discretion in dismissing jury to arraign defendant and take plea before reimpaneling and swearing 39 same jury for trial
- defendant had not pleaded to the indictment after his demurrer had been overruled
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: White
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
50 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Wade v. HunterSupreme Court· 1949-04-25· cited 1,511×
- Illinois v. SomervilleSupreme Court· 1973-02-27· cited 1,368×
- Crist v. BretzSupreme Court· 1978-06-14· cited 1,095×
- Gori v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1961-10-09· cited 679×
- Himmelfarb v. United StatesNinth Circuit· 1949-06-03· cited 159×
- United States v. Michael D. ShinaultTenth Circuit· 1998-07-08· cited 88×
- State v. FarmerSupreme Court of New Jersey· 1966-11-21· cited 76×
- State v. CypherIdaho Supreme Court· 1968-03-20· cited 62×
- Tommy McNeal v. William Hollowell, Superintendent, Mississippi State PenitentiaryFifth Circuit· 1973-11-23· cited 58×
- United States v. Jesus Reyes MendozaFifth Circuit· 1973-01-12· cited 55×
- United States v. WallsNinth Circuit· 1978-06-28· cited 48×
- United States v. Edward StarlingFifth Circuit· 1978-04-21· cited 43×
- The PEOPLE v. LawsIllinois Supreme Court· 1963-09-27· cited 37×
- United States v. Dante Edward GoriSecond Circuit· 1960-08-18· cited 36×
- State v. BergerNorth Dakota Supreme Court· 1975-11-04· cited 36×
- State v. BishopCourt of Appeals of Washington· 1971-12-20· cited 35×
- United States v. Solomon GloverSecond Circuit· 1974-10-04· cited 32×
- Will Allen Smith v. State of MississippiFifth Circuit· 1973-05-07· cited 31×
- United States v. Charles Spinella, Frank Leslie Merritt and Jerry BuchananFifth Circuit· 1975-01-13· cited 28×
- State v. NietoNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1967-06-19· cited 28×
Cites
2 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Other cases named Lovato v. New Mexico
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.