Lockhart v. Wills
Citations
- 9 N.M. 344
- 9 Gild. 344
Syllabus
<p>SYLLABUS BY THE COURT.</p> <p>Mining Lands — Spanish Grant — Location of Mine — Forfeiture— Ejectment — Harmless Error. — 1. Lands embraced within the boundaries of a Mexican or Spanish grant in New Mexico in 1893, as claimed and which was sub judiee in the court of private land claims, were open to exploration and purchase under the mining laws of the United States.</p> <p>2. (a) As against a subsequent locator, a location, not perfected according to the territorial laws, within the time pi;ovided becomes forfeited and void, and the ground- embraced therein becomes open to location.</p> <p>(b) Plaintiff, to maintain ejectment against a subsequent locator, must show a valid location.</p> <p>(e) When the facts produced by plaintiff show a forfeiture of his location has taken place, it is the duty of the court to instruct the jury to find for the defendants.</p> <p>3. Where facts show that a forfeiture of plaintiff’s location has taken place, for failure to perform the statutory requirements for a valid location, it is immaterial to show that such failure was a result of a conspiracy to defraud plaintiff on the part of plaintiff’s co-locator with other persons who locate after forfeiture.</p> <p>i. (a) The assigning of a wrong reason for an act by the trial court is not reversible error if the act done was in law right.</p> <p>(b) When the plaintiff’s case is inherently and fatally defective and is incurable, the defendant is entitled to have the judgment affirmed, notwithstanding error of the trial court.</p> <p>5. (a) When plaintiff allows his location to become forfeited by failure to perfect same, as required by law, he can not set up as an excuse for failure that prior to the expiration of the time allowed by law to perfect his location, others took adverse possession of his claim, of which he was not aware until after forfeiture.</p> <p>(b) In order for adverse possession and ouster to furnish an excuse for not perfecting the location of a mining claim, the p
Judges: Acker, Leland, McFie, Mills, Pabkeb
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
15 cases in this archive cite this case.
- State v. WhiteNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1954-05-12· cited 58×
- State Ex Rel. State Game Commission v. Red River Valley Co.New Mexico Supreme Court· 1945-09-24· cited 55×
- Natseway v. JojolaNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1952-12-26· cited 37×
- Lopez v. TownsendNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1938-09-24· cited 34×
- Wiggs v. City of AlbuquerqueNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1953-12-02· cited 24×
- Flanagan v. BenvieNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1954-08-05· cited 17×
- Sena v. SandersNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1950-01-12· cited 16×
- Lamonica v. BosenbergNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1964-02-03· cited 16×
- State Ex Rel. Sanchez v. StapletonNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1944-11-04· cited 16×
- Crumpacker v. AdamsNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1967-03-20· cited 12×
- Cartwright v. Public Service Company of New MexicoNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1959-06-01· cited 11×
- Adams v. BenedictNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1958-04-23· cited 8×
- McDermott v. SherNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1955-02-23· cited 8×
- Goldenberg v. Village of CapitanNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1951-02-10· cited 6×
- Walter v. RichardsonNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1956-11-02· cited 4×
Cites
13 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Belk v. MeagherSupreme Court· 1881-12-18· cited 306×
- Newhall v. SangerSupreme Court· 1876-05-18· cited 141×
- Doolan v. CarrSupreme Court· 1887-11-21· cited 122×
- Astiazaran v. Santa Rita Land & Mining Co.Supreme Court· 1893-03-06· cited 37×
- Hosmer v. WallaceSupreme Court· 1879-03-24· cited 34×
- Trenouth v. San FranciscoSupreme Court· 1880-01-19· cited 28×
- United States v. McLaughlinSupreme Court· 1888-05-14· cited 28×
- Wisconsin Central R. Co. v. ForsytheSupreme Court· 1895-06-03· cited 25×
- Bernards Township v. MorrisonSupreme Court· 1890-03-03· cited 19×
- Evans v. PikeSupreme Court· 1886-05-10· cited 12×
- Pinkerton v. LedouxSupreme Court· 1889-02-04· cited 12×
- Wisner v. BrownSupreme Court· 1887-05-27· cited 8×
- Aurrecoechea v. BangsSupreme Court· 1885-04-06· cited 3×
Other cases named Lockhart v. Wills
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.