Linz v. Schuck
Citations
- 67 A. 286
- 106 Md. 220
- 1907 Md. LEXIS 98
Syllabus
<p>Contracts — Consideration—Promise of Extra Pay to one who Refuses to Complete Contract — Substituted Agreement — Evidence.</p> <p>When one of the parties to a contract for the doing of certain work for a stipulated sum refuses, after part performance, to go on with the work, on account of substantial difficulties not foreseen at the time the contract was made, which would increase the cost of performance, a promise by the other party to pay an additional sum if the contractor will finish .the work is enforceable.</p> <p>In such case, it is not necessary that the original contract should be expressly rescinded, but the effect of the promise of extra pay and its acceptance is to substiiute a new and modified contract for the original agreement.*</p> <p>A merely moral obligation is not a consideration to support a promise.</p> <p>When defehdant promised a contractor for digging a cellar to pay, in addition to contract price, the extra cost of construction arising from the fact that soft mud was encountered under a crust of earth, evidence as to the sum paid by the contractor on this account is admissible in an action to recover the extra compensation.</p> <p>In such action, evidence is also admissible to show that certain payments made by the defendant were intended for a certain part of the work, and also to show the nature of the soil where the cellar was to be made.</p>
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- stating that modification is “an abandonment of the original contract and the creation of a new contract”
- a merely moral obligation is not sufficient consideration to transform a promise into a contract
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Briscoe, Boyd, Pearce, Schmucker, Burke, Rogers
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
33 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- n.sidney Nyhus v. Travel Management CorporationD.C. Circuit· 1972-08-11· cited 107×
- DirecTV, Inc. v. MattinglyCourt of Appeals of Maryland· 2003-07-31· cited 55×
- Berringer v. SteeleCourt of Special Appeals of Maryland· 2000-08-31· cited 51×
- Allstate Insurance v. StinebaughCourt of Appeals of Maryland· 2003-05-12· cited 46×
- Kerns v. Ætna Life Ins.Eighth Circuit· 1923-07-20· cited 36×
- White v. New York Life Ins. Co.Fifth Circuit· 1944-11-09· cited 29×
- Ætna Life Ins. Co. of Hartford v. RyanSecond Circuit· 1918-12-16· cited 27×
- Angel v. MurraySupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1974-07-22· cited 23×
- Stamatiades v. Merit Music Service, Inc.Court of Appeals of Maryland· 1956-08-27· cited 22×
- Department of Public Safety & Correctional Services v. Ara Health Services, Inc.Court of Special Appeals of Maryland· 1995-12-27· cited 20×
- Lange v. United StatesFourth Circuit· 1941-06-10· cited 18×
- Questar Homes of Avalon, LLC v. Pillar Construction, Inc.Court of Appeals of Maryland· 2005-09-09· cited 18×
- National School Studios, Inc. v. MealeyCourt of Appeals of Maryland· 1999-10-01· cited 18×
- Lowey v. WattD.C. Circuit· 1982-07-02· cited 16×
- Berger v. BurkoffCourt of Appeals of Maryland· 1952-11-07· cited 13×
- Savage v. North Anson Manufacturing Co.Supreme Judicial Court of Maine· 1924-06-05· cited 11×
- Gulf Oil Corporation v. Texas City Refining, Inc.Fourth Circuit· 1954-12-14· cited 9×
- Smith v. SmithCourt of Special Appeals of Maryland· 1989-06-09· cited 9×
- Rask v. NormanSupreme Court of Minnesota· 1918-12-13· cited 8×
- McComas v. Criminal Injuries Compensation BoardCourt of Special Appeals of Maryland· 1991-08-28· cited 6×
Cites
13 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Vanderbilt v. . SchreyerNew York Court of Appeals· 1883-03-06· cited 85×
- Ellicott v. TurnerCourt of Appeals of Maryland· 1853-12-15· cited 68×
- Lingenfelder v. Wainwright Brewing Co.Supreme Court of Missouri· 1890-10-15· cited 51×
- King v. Duluth, Missabe & Northern Railway Co.Supreme Court of Minnesota· 1895-06-28· cited 45×
- Rogers v. Rogers & BrotherMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1885-06-20· cited 37×
- Cooke v. MurphyIllinois Supreme Court· 1873-09-15· cited 36×
- Goebel v. LinnMichigan Supreme Court· 1882-01-18· cited 33×
- Meech v. . the City of BuffaloNew York Court of Appeals· 1864-03-05· cited 20×
- Robinson v. HurstCourt of Appeals of Maryland· 1893-06-21· cited 18×
- Connelly v. DevoeSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1871-02-15· cited 17×
- Drury v. BriscoeCourt of Appeals of Maryland· 1875-03-12· cited 13×
- Agel & Levin v. F. R. Patch Mfg. Co.Supreme Court of Vermont· 1904-08-26· cited 7×
- New Jersey Trust & Safe Deposit Co. v. National Gas & Construction Co.Supreme Court of New Jersey· 1904-06-13· cited 1×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.