Lewis v. Taylor
Citations
- 2017 COA 13
Syllabus
Ponzi Scheme—Colorado Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act—Principal—Net Profits—Innocent Investor—Reasonably Equivalent Value. Taylor invested $3 million in a hedge fund run by Mueller, a licensed securities broker. During the period of his investment, Taylor received a series of payments from the fund. Taylor withdrew all of his money about one year after investing and made a profit of over $487,000. Later, the Colorado securities commissioner discovered that the hedge fund was a Ponzi scheme and Mueller was convicted of various criminal offenses. Lewis was appointed receiver to collect and distribute Mueller's assets to the creditors and investors he defrauded through the Ponzi scheme. Lewis filed a claim under the Colorado Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act (CUFTA) seeking to void the transfer of net profits that Taylor received. The district court granted Lewis summary judgment. The Court of Appeals considered this case on remand to \address whether CUFTA requires Taylor to relinquish any amount of money exceeding his principal investment in the Ponzi scheme.\ The parties agreed that Taylor was an innocent investor he withdrew his principal and profits in good faith and he gave reasonably equivalent value for the return of his principal. The parties disagreed whether Taylor gave reasonably equivalent value in exchange for his receipt of the net profits. Taylor argued that the district court erred by ruling that he did not give reasonably equivalent value for transfers he received that exceeded his principal investment. The Court reasoned that a Ponzi scheme receives benefit for using an innocent investor's money for a period of time, regardless of whether the money is used for proper or fraudulent purposes, and the use of the money for a period of time has value. An innocent investor in a Ponzi scheme may be entitled to keep some of the funds exceeding the principal amount if such funds constituted a reasonably equivalent value on the principal investment. Therefore, t
Cited by
1 case in this archive cites this case.
Cites
13 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Hamon Contractors, Inc. v. Carter & Burgess, Inc.Colorado Court of Appeals· 2009-08-14· cited 236×
- Donell v. KowellNinth Circuit· 2008-07-01· cited 208×
- Leverage Leasing Co. v. SmithColorado Court of Appeals· 2006-08-10· cited 175×
- City of Greenwood Village v. for the Proposed City of CentennialSupreme Court of Colorado· 2000-06-26· cited 145×
- Scholes v. LehmannSeventh Circuit· 1995-07-12· cited 95×
- Balaber-Strauss v. Sixty-Five Brokers (In Re Churchill Mortgage Investment Corp.)S.D. New York· 2000-12-26· cited 77×
- Premier Farm Credit, PCA v. W-CATTLE, LLCColorado Court of Appeals· 2006-10-05· cited 63×
- Daly v. Deptula (In Re Carrozzella & Richardson)D. Connecticut· 2002-08-01· cited 54×
- Lewis v. TaylorSupreme Court of Colorado· 2016-06-20· cited 51×
- Grochocinski v. Zeigler (In Re Zeigler)N.D. Illinois· 2005-02-10· cited 44×
- Fischbach v. HolzberleinColorado Court of Appeals· 2009-06-11· cited 30×
- Lustig v. Weisz (In Re Unified Commercial Capital, Inc.)W.D. New York· 2001-03-29· cited 22×
- Schempp v. Lucre Management Group, LLCColorado Court of Appeals· 2000-07-20· cited 16×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.