First Circuit· 1/8/2002
LaRocca v. Borden, Inc.
Citations
- 276 F.3d 22
- 27 Employee Benefits Cas. (BNA) 1262
- 2002 U.S. App. LEXIS 224
- 2002 WL 10190
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- explaining that plaintiffs are “permanently ineligible for relief’ under Section 502(a)(1) when the ERISA plan is no longer functioning
- concluding that, after the district court constructively reinstated employees who had been improperly terminated from an ERISA plan, they were not entitled to further equitable relief under § 502(a)(3) because they could recover benefits due under the plan via § 502(a)(1)(B)
- explaining that if a plaintiff can pursue a claim to recover benefits or achieve constructive reinstatement in a plan pursuant to Section 1132(a)(1)(B), there is an adequate remedy under the plan, which bars a further remedy under Section 1132(a)(3)
- noting, in the context of summary judgment that “when the plaintiff can bring a claim for benefits under [§ 502(a)(1)], . . . she does not have a cause of action under [§ 502(a)(3)].” (citation modified)
- “The plaintiffs here were only ineligible for a remedy pursuant to Section [1132](a)(l)[ (B) ] because they were not members of the Plan when they filed suit”
- “[W]e cannot countenance a plaintiff’s agreeing to settle a case 26 in open court, than subsequently disavowing the settlement when it suits her.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Torruella, Gibson, Lipez
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
47 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Innova Hosp. San Antonio, Ltd. v. Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Ga., Inc.Fifth Circuit· 2018-06-12· cited 202×
- United States Ex Rel. Gagne v. City of WorcesterFirst Circuit· 2009-05-08· cited 189×
- Brody v. Stone & Webster, Inc.First Circuit· 2005-07-14· cited 112×
- Feliciano-Hernandez v. Pereira-CastilloFirst Circuit· 2011-12-09· cited 94×
- Goodwin Ex Rel. Estate of Lunnin v. C.N.J., Inc.First Circuit· 2006-01-30· cited 57×
- Merrimon v. Unum Life Insurance Co. of AmericaFirst Circuit· 2014-07-02· cited 55×
- United States Ex. Rel. Kelly v. Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corp.First Circuit· 2016-06-17· cited 53×
- David Ogden, Camilla Ogden v. Blue Bell CreameriesEleventh Circuit· 2003-10-28· cited 35×
- Barrs v. Lockheed Martin Corp.First Circuit· 2002-04-24· cited 27×
- Nahigian v. LeonardD. Massachusetts· 2002-11-22· cited 21×
- Alves v. Harvard Pilgrim Health Care, Inc.D. Massachusetts· 2002-06-04· cited 17×
- ACA Financial Guaranty Corp. v. Advest, Inc.First Circuit· 2008-01-10· cited 15×
- Utility Workers, Local 369 v. NSTAR Electric & Gas Corp.D. Massachusetts· 2004-05-12· cited 13×
- Massey v. Stanley-Bostitch, Inc.D. Rhode Island· 2003-03-28· cited 9×
- King v. UNUM Life Insurance Co. of AmericaD. Maine· 2002-09-19· cited 8×
- Tebo v. Sedgwick Claims Management Services, Inc.D. Massachusetts· 2012-01-24· cited 7×
- Joyce v. John Hancock Financial Services, Inc.D. Massachusetts· 2006-11-22· cited 6×
- Kourinos v. Interstate Brands Corp.D. Maine· 2004-05-14· cited 6×
- Papadopoulos v. Hartford Life InsuranceD. Massachusetts· 2005-07-19· cited 6×
- Curran v. Camden National Corp.D. Maine· 2007-02-28· cited 5×
Cites
20 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Foman v. DavisSupreme Court· 1962-12-03· cited 17,205×
- Pilot Life Insurance v. DedeauxSupreme Court· 1987-04-06· cited 3,459×
- Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance v. RussellSupreme Court· 1985-06-27· cited 1,937×
- Varity Corp. v. HoweSupreme Court· 1996-03-19· cited 1,806×
- Mertens v. Hewitt AssociatesSupreme Court· 1993-06-01· cited 1,574×
- FMC Corp. v. HollidaySupreme Court· 1990-11-27· cited 950×
- Forsyth v. Humana, Inc.Ninth Circuit· 1997-05-23· cited 672×
- Humana Inc. v. ForsythSupreme Court· 1999-01-20· cited 262×
- Resolution Trust Corp. v. GoldFirst Circuit· 1994-07-28· cited 157×
- Acosta-Mestre v. Hilton International of Puerto Rico, Inc.First Circuit· 1998-08-26· cited 146×
- Thomas R. Lussier v. Marvin Runyon, United States Postmaster General, Thomas R. Lussier v. Marvin Runyon, United States Postmaster GeneralFirst Circuit· 1995-03-29· cited 140×
- George Kwatcher v. Massachusetts Service Employees Pension FundFirst Circuit· 1989-07-05· cited 139×
- Rebecca Judge v. City of LowellFirst Circuit· 1998-11-18· cited 136×
- Grant v. News Group Boston, Inc.First Circuit· 1995-04-28· cited 134×
- Dorothy E. Travitz v. Northeast Department Ilgwu Health and Welfare Fund Ilgwu Eastern States Health and Welfare FundThird Circuit· 1994-01-10· cited 83×
- Turner v. Fallon Community Health Plan, Inc.First Circuit· 1997-10-20· cited 80×
- Ferne B. Katz v. Comprehensive Plan of Group Insurance, Alltel Pension and Benefits CommitteeEleventh Circuit· 2000-02-09· cited 67×
- Jeffrey Ream v. Jeffrey E. Frey Fulton Bank Laurie L. Frey Fulton BankThird Circuit· 1997-02-14· cited 45×
- Jackson v. Truck Drivers' Union Local 42 Health & Welfare FundD. Massachusetts· 1996-08-07· cited 13×
- United Steelworkers v. Newman-Crosby Steel, Inc.D. Rhode Island· 1993-06-04· cited 11×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.