Kirkpatrick's Estate
Citations
- 275 Pa. 271
- 119 A. 269
- 1922 Pa. LEXIS 493
Syllabus
<p>Taxation — Transfer inheritance tax — Nature of tax — Deduction of federal inheritance tax — Act of June 20, 1919, P. L. 521 — Uniformity.</p> <p>1. The inheritance transfer tax of June 20,1919, P. L. 521, does not impose a tax on property, but requires payment from the estate of a decedent for the right of succession or the privilege of receiving at death the property possessed by decedent.</p> <p>2. In computing a transfer inheritance tax under the Act of June 20, 1919, on the estate of a Pennsylvania decedent, the sum paid to the federal government as an estate tax cannot be deducted, inasmuch as the legislature intended this tax should be based on the clear value of the estate before deducting the federal tax.</p> <p>3. The requirement that the federal tax shall not be deducted from the value of the estate in determining the state tax, does not involve lack of uniformity, for all estates are classed exactly alike.</p> <p>4. The Act of June 20,1919, is not to be declared unworkable, because there is no provision as to how the charge may be worked out among the several legatees, distributees and residuary claimants.</p> <p>5. The right of the state to create a right to inherit, and the right to demand an excise for such right of inheritance, cannot be legislated out of existence or interfered with simply because the federal government sees fit to levy a graduated tax on the same subject of taxation — a state-created right.</p> <p>6. The subject of the tax imposed by the Act of June 20, 1919, is not a matter of concurrent legislation, and may be taken away by the State, leaving the federal government without this subject to tax.</p> <p>Mr. Justice Frazer dissented.</p>
Judges: Frazer, Kephabt, Kephart, Moschzisker, Sadler, Schaffer, Simpson, Walling
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
24 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Dolan's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1924-03-10· cited 84×
- Frick's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1923-04-30· cited 42×
- Maginn's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1923-06-23· cited 40×
- Estate of RoseSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1975-11-26· cited 29×
- Wright EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1958-01-22· cited 22×
- Oberdorfer EstatePhiladelphia County Orphans' Court· 1960-01-12· cited 2×
- Wurts v. CommissionerBoard of Tax Appeals· 1927-04-29· cited 1×
- In re Estate of BanksCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania· 1989-07-18· cited 1×
- Commonwealth v. TaylorDauphin County Court of Common Pleas· 1922-12-18· cited 1×
- Koenig's EstateDauphin County Orphans' Court· 1934-12-17· cited 1×
- Mertz EstateLehigh County Orphans' Court· 1955-12-14· cited 1×
- Untitled Texas Attorney General OpinionTexas Attorney General Reports· 1940-07-02
- Butler's EstateNorthumberland County Orphans' Court· 1933-01-30
- Bernstein's EstatePhiladelphia County Orphans' Court· 1936-03-27
- Yontz v. YontzDauphin County Court of Common Pleas· 1941-02-26
- Oberholzer's EstateLancaster County Orphans' Court· 1943-01-29
- Haupt's EstateNorthampton County Orphans' Court· 1946-04-20
- Bonsall EstatePhiladelphia County Orphans' Court· 1948-10-27
- Cowan EstateWestmoreland County Orphans' Court· 1951-11-21
- Oberheide EstatePhiladelphia County Orphans' Court· 1956-12-07
Cites
8 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Knowlton v. MooreSupreme Court· 1900-05-14· cited 739×
- United States v. PerkinsSupreme Court· 1896-05-25· cited 241×
- Plummer v. ColerSupreme Court· 1900-05-14· cited 196×
- Hooper v. ShawMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1900-05-18· cited 32×
- In re the Appraisal for Taxation of the Estate of ShermanAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1917-07-02· cited 19×
- Finnen's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1900-05-14· cited 16×
- Jackson v. MyersSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1917-03-12· cited 16×
- In re the Transfer Tax upon the Estate of BierstadtAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1917-07-13· cited 12×
Other cases named Kirkpatrick's Estate
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.