Tenth Circuit· 2/2/2007
Karr v. Hefner
Citations
- 475 F.3d 1192
- 64 ERC 1481
- 37 Envtl. L. Rep. (Envtl. Law Inst.) 20036
- 64 ERC (BNA) 1481
- 2007 U.S. App. LEXIS 2312
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- concluding that compliance with the CWA’s notice requirement is jurisdictional
- finding the plaintiff’s pre-suit notice letter insufficient where it alleged that pollution from “construction activities” was being discharged from the defendant’s well rather than from any point sources actually associated with its construction activities
- statute “does not require government prosecution to be far-reaching or zealous. It requires only diligence.”
- “In sum, our evaluation of the EPA’s diligence is quite deferential. Citizen-plaintiffs must meet a high standard to demonstrate that it has failed to prosecute a violation diligently.”
- \[A]n agency's prosecutorial strategy [need not] coincide with that of the citizen-plaintiff.\
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Tacha, Briscoe, Hartz
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
32 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Chesapeake Bay Foundation, Inc. v. Severstal Sparrows Point, LLCD. Maryland· 2011-07-05· cited 415×
- Group Against Smog & Pollution, Inc. v. Shenango Inc.Third Circuit· 2016-01-06· cited 338×
- Environmental Conservation Organization v. City of DallasFifth Circuit· 2008-05-27· cited 205×
- Piney Run Preservation Ass'n v. County Commissioners of Carroll CountyFourth Circuit· 2008-04-23· cited 140×
- National Parks & Conservation Ass'n v. Tennessee Valley AuthorityEleventh Circuit· 2007-10-04· cited 61×
- Hancock v. Metropolitan Life InsuranceTenth Circuit· 2009-12-29· cited 56×
- Cebollero-Bertran v. PR Aqueduct & Sewer AuthorityFirst Circuit· 2021-07-01· cited 56×
- City of Birmingham Retirement & Relief System v. GoodSupreme Court of Delaware· 2017-12-15· cited 41×
- Benham v. Ozark Materials River Rock, LLCTenth Circuit· 2018-03-22· cited 27×
- Ohio Valley Environmental Coalition, Inc. v. Maple Coal Co.S.D. West Virginia· 2011-09-02· cited 24×
- Yadkin Riverkeeper, Inc. v. Duke Energy Carolinas, LLCM.D. North Carolina· 2015-10-20· cited 21×
- Sierra Club v. Two Elk Generation Partners, Ltd. PartnershipTenth Circuit· 2011-05-31· cited 17×
- HealthTrio, Inc. v. Centennial River Corp. (In Re Healthrio, Inc.)Tenth Circuit· 2011-08-05· cited 14×
- Assateague Coastkeeper v. Alan & Kristin Hudson FarmD. Maryland· 2010-07-21· cited 14×
- Godfrey v. Upland BoroughE.D. Pennsylvania· 2017-03-30· cited 13×
- South River Watershed Alliance v. DeKalb County, GeorgiaEleventh Circuit· 2023-05-31· cited 8×
- Shark River Cleanup Coalition v. Township of WallThird Circuit· 2022-08-24· cited 6×
- SPS Ltd. Partnership, LLLP v. Severstal Sparrows Point, LLCD. Maryland· 2011-07-05· cited 6×
- HEAL Utah v. PacifiCorpD. Utah· 2019-03-22· cited 5×
- Hernandez v. ESSO STANDARD OIL CO.(PUERTO RICO)D. Puerto Rico· 2008-07-10· cited 4×
Cites
16 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Gwaltney of Smithfield, Ltd. v. Chesapeake Bay Foundation, Inc.Supreme Court· 1987-12-01· cited 955×
- Smith v. PlatiTenth Circuit· 2001-07-30· cited 231×
- Parker v. ScottTenth Circuit· 2005-01-05· cited 151×
- Public Interest Research Group of New Jersey, Inc., Friends of the Earth in No. 93-5721 v. Hercules, Inc. In No. 93-5720Third Circuit· 1995-03-31· cited 104×
- North and South Rivers Watershed Association, Inc. v. Town of ScituateFirst Circuit· 1992-01-14· cited 95×
- Atlantic States Legal Foundation, Inc. v. Stroh Die Casting Co.Seventh Circuit· 1997-06-17· cited 86×
- Sierra Club v. El Paso Gold Mines, Inc.Tenth Circuit· 2005-08-24· cited 83×
- Supporters to Oppose Pollution, Inc. v. The Heritage GroupSeventh Circuit· 1992-10-05· cited 78×
- Ellis v. Gallatin Steel Co.Sixth Circuit· 2004-10-26· cited 77×
- Seneca-Cayuga Tribe v. National Indian Gaming CommissionTenth Circuit· 2003-04-17· cited 61×
- Connecticut Fund for the Environment v. Contract Plating Co.D. Connecticut· 1986-04-04· cited 35×
- Williams Pipe Line Co. v. Bayer Corp.S.D. Iowa· 1997-04-14· cited 28×
- California Sportfishing Protection Alliance v. City of West SacramentoE.D. California· 1995-10-24· cited 20×
- Community of Cambridge Environmental Health and Community Development Group v. City of CambridgeD. Maryland· 2000-08-23· cited 14×
- Chesapeake Bay Foundation v. American Recovery Co.Fourth Circuit· 1985-08-05· cited 13×
- Sierra Club v. El Paso Gold Mines, Inc.D. Colorado· 2002-04-11· cited 4×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.