Sixth Circuit· 2/18/2005
Joseph J. Simon v. Pfizer Incorporated
Citations
- 398 F.3d 765
- 22 I.E.R. Cas. (BNA) 858
- 34 Employee Benefits Cas. (BNA) 1673
- 2005 U.S. App. LEXIS 2881
- 2005 WL 383709
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that plaintiffs claims were not covered where the claims “require consideration of some factual issues that are subject to arbitration, but ... have independent legal bases,” including establishing “termination for gross misconduct” as opposed to “termination for Just Cause”
- noting that the scope of arbitration provisions is confined to the scope of the two sections that provide for arbitration
- holding ERISA and COBRA claims were not within the scope of an arbitration provision where the agreement did not refer to either.
- “When faced with a broad arbitration clause, such as one covering any dispute arising out of an agreement, a court should follow the presumption of arbitration and resolve doubts in favor of arbitration.”
- “[B]ecause Pfizer appeals, in part on the District Court’s refusal to enforce, through dismissal or stay, an agreement to arbitrate, this Court has independent jurisdiction over that question under the Federal Arbitration Act (“FAA”
- interpreting “any dispute arising out of an agreement” broadly
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Siler, Rogers, Forester
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
40 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Nestle Waters North America, Inc. v. BollmanSixth Circuit· 2007-10-12· cited 78×
- Turi v. Main Street Adoption Services, LLPSixth Circuit· 2011-03-04· cited 69×
- Roger Smith v. Aegon Companies Pension PlanSixth Circuit· 2014-10-14· cited 63×
- United Steelworkers of America, Afl-Cio, Clc v. Cooper Tire & Rubber CompanySixth Circuit· 2007-01-17· cited 58×
- Solvay Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Duramed Pharmaceuticals, Inc.Sixth Circuit· 2006-03-22· cited 57×
- Jones v. U-Haul Co.S.D. Ohio· 2014-04-23· cited 50×
- Romil Rafael Estrella Taveras v. Carolyn R. Paiewonsky TaverazSixth Circuit· 2007-02-16· cited 49×
- NCR Corp. v. Korala Associates, Ltd.Sixth Circuit· 2008-01-16· cited 45×
- AtriCure, Inc. v. Jian MengSixth Circuit· 2021-08-27· cited 44×
- James Smith v. Board of Directors of Triad MaSeventh Circuit· 2021-09-10· cited 44×
- Albert M. Higley Company v. N/s CorporationSixth Circuit· 2006-04-17· cited 38×
- Teamsters Local Union 480 v. United Parcel Service, Inc.Sixth Circuit· 2014-04-04· cited 36×
- VIP, Inc. v. KYB Corp.Sixth Circuit· 2020-02-24· cited 36×
- Michael Southard v. Newcomb Oil Co., LLCSixth Circuit· 2021-08-04· cited 31×
- Gary Glenn v. Eric Holder, Jr.Sixth Circuit· 2012-08-02· cited 30×
- Brookdale Senior Living Inc. v. StacyE.D. Kentucky· 2014-06-20· cited 26×
- Brubaker v. BarrettE.D. Tennessee· 2011-07-15· cited 24×
- Raymond Hawkins v. Cintas Corp.Sixth Circuit· 2022-04-27· cited 20×
- Stachurski v. DirecTV, Inc.N.D. Ohio· 2009-07-13· cited 18×
- State v. Philip Morris Inc.Court of Special Appeals of Maryland· 2008-03-27· cited 14×
Cites
34 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Cohen v. Beneficial Industrial Loan Corp.Supreme Court· 1949-06-20· cited 10,863×
- Moses H. Cone Memorial Hospital v. Mercury Construction Corp.Supreme Court· 1983-02-23· cited 9,657×
- United Steelworkers v. Warrior & Gulf Navigation Co.Supreme Court· 1960-06-20· cited 5,791×
- At&T Technologies, Inc. v. Communications WorkersSupreme Court· 1986-04-07· cited 4,474×
- Mitsubishi Motors Corp. v. Soler Chrysler-Plymouth, Inc.Supreme Court· 1985-07-02· cited 3,702×
- Dean Witter Reynolds Inc. v. ByrdSupreme Court· 1985-03-04· cited 2,684×
- Shearson/American Express Inc. v. McMahonSupreme Court· 1987-09-21· cited 1,711×
- Gulfstream Aerospace Corp. v. Mayacamas Corp.Supreme Court· 1988-03-22· cited 1,035×
- Kevin W. Ziegler v. Ibp Hog Market, Inc.Sixth Circuit· 2001-04-30· cited 460×
- Judy Lynn Tahfs, Plaintiff-Appellant/cross-Appellee v. William N. Proctor Miranda K. Proctor, Defendants-Appellees/cross-AppellantsSixth Circuit· 2003-01-14· cited 364×
- Hill v. City of New YorkSecond Circuit· 1995-01-17· cited 265×
- Pritzker v. Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith, Inc.Third Circuit· 1993-10-15· cited 255×
- Santiago Amaro v. The Continental Can CompanyNinth Circuit· 1984-01-23· cited 180×
- Robert P. Brennan v. Township of Northville, Lawrence Demeter and Fred Yankee, Individually and in Their Official CapacitiesSixth Circuit· 1996-03-26· cited 132×
- Masco Corporation v. Zurich American Insurance Company, Near North Insurance Agency, Inc.Sixth Circuit· 2004-08-31· cited 112×
- 57 soc.sec.rep.ser. 220, Medicare & Medicaid Guide P 46,329 Robert Chambers v. Ohio Department of Human ServicesSixth Circuit· 1998-05-27· cited 107×
- Kramer v. Smith BarneyFifth Circuit· 1996-04-23· cited 59×
- Roney and Company v. Sam Kassab Akram SemaanSixth Circuit· 1992-12-14· cited 59×
- United Steelworkers of America, for Itself and on Behalf of Local 12943 v. The Mead Corporation, Fine Paper DivisionSixth Circuit· 1994-04-11· cited 58×
- Bratt Enterprises, Incorporated v. Noble International Ltd. Set Enterprises Inc.Sixth Circuit· 2003-07-31· cited 55×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.