Jean Dedmon v. Debbie Steelman
Citations
- 535 S.W.3d 431
Syllabus
We granted this appeal to address whether our holding in West v. Shelby County Healthcare Corp., 459 S.W.3d 33 (Tenn. 2014), applies in personal injury cases. We hold that it does not. West held that \reasonable charges\ for medical services under Tennessee's Hospital Lien Act, Tennessee Code Annotated sections 29-22-101 to –107 (2012), are the discounted amounts a hospital accepts as full payment from patients' private insurers, not the full, undiscounted amounts billed to patients. West, 459 S.W.3d at 46. West defined \reasonable charges\ in the context of interpreting the Hospital Lien Act, and its holding is limited to that Act. As an alternative argument, we are asked in this appeal to consider applying the principles in West to the determination of reasonable medical expenses in personal injury cases. Doing so involves the collateral source rule, which excludes evidence of benefits to the plaintiff from sources collateral to the tortfeasor and precludes the reduction of the plaintiff's damage award by such collateral payments. The rule is based on the principles that tortfeasors should be responsible for all of the harm they cause and that payments from collateral sources intended to benefit an injured party should not be used to reduce the liability of the party who inflicted the injury. After a thorough review of court decisions in Tennessee and across the country on the collateral source rule, we decline to alter existing law in Tennessee. We hold that the collateral source rule applies in this personal injury case, in which the collateral benefit at issue is private insurance. Consequently, the plaintiffs may submit evidence of the injured party's full, undiscounted medical bills as proof of reasonable medical expenses. Furthermore, the defendants are precluded from submitting evidence of discounted rates accepted by medical providers from the insurer to rebut the plaintiffs' proof that the full, undiscounted charges are reasonable. The defendants remain f
Judges: Justice Holly Kirby
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
14 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Weston v. AKHappytime, LLCAlaska Supreme Court· 2019-08-02· cited 13×
- Turnage v. OldhamW.D. Tennessee· 2018-10-15· cited 11×
- Angela Stevens v. State of TennesseeCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-02-28
- In Re Estate of Sylvia Marene Tolbert v. State ot TennesseeCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-02-28
- Kristin McKenzie Women's Health Services-Chattanooga, P.C.Court of Appeals of Tennessee· 2018-08-20
- Jerry Cox v. Water and Wastewater Treatment Authority Of Wilson County, TennesseeCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2020-01-31
- Kimberly Sue Noland v. Matthew Cook, Administrator Ad Litem of Estate of Ronnie Sue LoweCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2020-03-27
- Shelby K. Marsh v. Angela D. LoweCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2020-04-29
- Cynthia E. Yebuah v. Center for Urological Treatment, PLCCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2020-05-28
- Theresa Doty v. City of Johnson CityCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2021-07-07
- Robert Crotty v. Mark Flora, M.D.Tennessee Supreme Court· 2023-09-29
- Tatum M. Campbell v. T.C. Restaurant Group, LLCCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2025-03-04
- JEFF HURST v. CITY OF MORRISTOWNCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2025-07-08
- Marilyn Butcher v. Shelby County Board of EducationCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 2025-10-10
Cites
88 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Michelle RYE Et Al. v. WOMEN’S CARE CENTER OF MEMPHIS, MPLLC Et Al.Tennessee Supreme Court· 2015-10-26· cited 984×
- Overstreet v. Shoney's, Inc.Court of Appeals of Tennessee· 1999-06-04· cited 522×
- McDermott, Inc. v. AmClydeSupreme Court· 1994-04-20· cited 322×
- Colonial Pipeline Co. v. MorganTennessee Supreme Court· 2008-09-09· cited 257×
- Verska v. Saint Alphonsus Regional Medical CenterIdaho Supreme Court· 2011-11-09· cited 251×
- Helfend v. Southern California Rapid Transit DistrictCalifornia Supreme Court· 1970-02-18· cited 204×
- Robinson v. BatesOhio Supreme Court· 2006-12-20· cited 173×
- Aaron Glenn Haygood v. Margarita Garza De EscabedoTexas Supreme Court· 2011-07-01· cited 160×
- Bozeman v. StateSupreme Court of Louisiana· 2004-07-02· cited 131×
- Howell v. HAMILTON MEATS & PROVISIONS, INC.California Supreme Court· 2011-08-18· cited 116×
- Coakley v. DanielsCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 1992-02-28· cited 115×
- Moorhead v. Crozer Chester Medical CenterSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2001-01-29· cited 112×
- Benson v. Tennessee Valley Electric CooperativeCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 1993-04-30· cited 97×
- Arthur v. CatourIllinois Supreme Court· 2005-07-21· cited 95×
- Hanif v. Housing AuthorityCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1988-04-21· cited 95×
- Wills v. FosterIllinois Supreme Court· 2008-06-19· cited 91×
- Grissom v. GleasonSupreme Court of Georgia· 1992-07-09· cited 90×
- Acuar v. LetourneauSupreme Court of Virginia· 2000-06-09· cited 89×
- Denton v. Con-Way Southern Express, Inc.Supreme Court of Georgia· 1991-03-15· cited 86×
- Aundrey MEALS Ex Rel. William MEALS v. FORD MOTOR COMPANYTennessee Supreme Court· 2013-08-30· cited 79×
Other cases named Jean Dedmon v. Debbie Steelman
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.