Ninth Circuit· 8/2/1989
James W. Menefield v. Robert G. Borg, Warden
Citations
- 881 F.2d 696
- 1989 U.S. App. LEXIS 11243
- 1989 WL 84618
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- noting that a defendant’s decision to represent him- or herself is not “cast in stone”
- \We... hold that... an accused who requests an attorney at the time of a motion for a new trial is entitled to have one appointed\
- “[b]ecause of the centrality of the right to counsel, we will not deny a defendant that right during a critical stage of the prosecution unless compelling circumstances require us to .do so”
- citations to Mempa v. Rhay, 389 U.S. 128 (1967), and United States v. Ash, 413 U.S. 300 (1973), omitted
- “We are certainly unwilling to deny counsel because of some conception that the defendant’s initial decision to exercise his Faretta right and represent himself at trial is a choice cast in stone.”
- “A trial court cannot insist that a defendant continue representing himself out of some punitive notion that the defendant, having made his bed, should be compelled to lie in it.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Schroeder, Reinhardt, Leavy
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
81 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Marshall v. RodgersSupreme Court· 2013-04-01· cited 676×
- Antonio Darnell Robinson v. John Ignacio, WardenNinth Circuit· 2004-03-10· cited 437×
- Richard Adams Hovey v. Robert L. Ayers, Jr., Acting Warden, California State Prison at San QuentinNinth Circuit· 2006-08-11· cited 223×
- Vernon Jackson v. Eddie YlstNinth Circuit· 1990-12-13· cited 207×
- Biodex Corporation v. Loredan Biomedical, Inc.Federal Circuit· 1991-10-03· cited 174×
- United States v. RhynesFourth Circuit· 1999-10-26· cited 160×
- United States v. Calvin Lyniol RobinsonNinth Circuit· 1990-08-31· cited 131×
- Hidalgo v. StateCourt of Criminal Appeals of Texas· 1999-01-13· cited 113×
- United States v. Drago Carl MusaNinth Circuit· 2000-07-24· cited 112×
- People v. KoontzCalifornia Supreme Court· 2002-05-09· cited 112×
- State v. McKinneyArizona Supreme Court· 1996-05-16· cited 94×
- United States v. A.R., a Male Juvenile, A.R.Third Circuit· 1994-10-25· cited 83×
- United States v. Hojatollah Tajeddini, Hojatollah Tajeddini v. United StatesFirst Circuit· 1991-09-26· cited 71×
- United States v. ProctorFirst Circuit· 1999-01-31· cited 69×
- UNITED STATES of America, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. Alberto Jose DEL MURO, AKA Raul Torres-Garcia, Defendant-AppellantNinth Circuit· 1996-07-01· cited 69×
- People v. LawrenceCalifornia Supreme Court· 2009-04-30· cited 69×
- United States v. Rick Paul SpringerNinth Circuit· 1995-04-03· cited 67×
- State v. ReedSupreme Court of South Carolina· 1998-07-27· cited 63×
- United States v. John Francis HarringtonNinth Circuit· 2005-06-06· cited 62×
- United States v. LevetoThird Circuit· 2008-08-26· cited 57×
Cites
30 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Chapman v. CaliforniaSupreme Court· 1967-03-27· cited 23,069×
- Penson v. OhioSupreme Court· 1988-11-29· cited 13,912×
- Faretta v. CaliforniaSupreme Court· 1975-06-30· cited 11,585×
- United States v. WadeSupreme Court· 1967-06-12· cited 8,442×
- Gideon v. WainwrightSupreme Court· 1963-03-18· cited 8,419×
- Powell v. AlabamaSupreme Court· 1932-11-07· cited 4,979×
- Douglas v. CaliforniaSupreme Court· 1963-04-29· cited 3,330×
- Illinois v. AllenSupreme Court· 1970-04-06· cited 3,248×
- Holloway v. ArkansasSupreme Court· 1978-04-03· cited 2,478×
- Estelle v. SmithSupreme Court· 1981-05-18· cited 2,053×
- Mempa v. RhaySupreme Court· 1967-11-13· cited 1,589×
- White v. MarylandSupreme Court· 1963-04-29· cited 1,066×
- United States v. AshSupreme Court· 1973-06-21· cited 868×
- United States v. Ruth StudleyNinth Circuit· 1986-02-26· cited 671×
- Antonelli v. Federal Bureau of InvestigationSupreme Court· 1984-05-21· cited 198×
- Grandison v. StateCourt of Appeals of Maryland· 1986-04-01· cited 149×
- People v. McDanielCalifornia Supreme Court· 1976-02-11· cited 132×
- E. I. Du Pont de Nemours & Co. v. MaloneySupreme Court· 1966-03-21· cited 108×
- United States v. Richard LeavittNinth Circuit· 1979-11-26· cited 96×
- United States v. Richard W. (Dick) Rylander, Sr.Ninth Circuit· 1983-09-02· cited 89×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.