Irvin v. Irvin
Citations
- 142 Pa. 271
- 21 A. 816
- 1891 Pa. LEXIS 734
Syllabus
<p>[To be reported.]</p> <p>(а) By a contract under seal the defendant, in consideration of certain things to be done by the plaintiff, a married woman, covenanted to pay her six thousand dollars, four thousand dollars of that sum to be secured by a promissory note, with an approved indorser, to be delivered to plaintiff’s attorneys “ as custodians for the parties.”</p> <p>(б) Accordingly, anote drawn to the order of a third person, and indorsed by the payee in blank, was delivered to plaintiff’s attorneys. Plaintiff performed her covenants specified in the written contract, but the note was never delivered to her. In an action for the amount thereof, she called one of said attorneys to prove and identify the note:</p> <p>1. It was error to permit the witness to testify, on cross-examination and under objection, that, by a contemporaneous parol stipulation, intentionally omitted from the written contract, the plaintiff agreed, as part of the consideration of the note, that she would secure a divorce from her husband, and should not receive the note until then.</p> <p>2. Such testimony, if admissible at all, was so only by way of defence as part of the defendant’s case; and, therefore, the alleged oral agreement being denied by the plaintiff, it was error to direct a verdict for the defendant, on the ground that the plaintiff’s case exhibited a transaction tainted with illegality.</p> <p>8. Whether the testimony would have been admissible at any time or for any purpose, doubted: “I know of no decided case, and no principle of law, which permits an oral contract, made at the same time with a written contract under seal, and purposely omitted therefrom, to be set up, not only to contradict, but to destroy it: “Per Mr. Chief Justice Paxson.</p>
Judges: McCollum, Mitchell, Paxson, Sterkett, Williams
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
31 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Grubb v. RockeySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1951-03-19· cited 64×
- Boyd EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1958-10-09· cited 45×
- Berger v. Pittsburgh Auto Equipment Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1956-11-27· cited 44×
- Union Storage Co. ex rel. Liverpool & London & Globe Insurance v. SpeckSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1899-12-30· cited 40×
- Scott v. Bryn Mawr ArmsSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1973-11-26· cited 38×
- Colozzi v. Bevko, Inc.Supreme Court of New Jersey· 1955-01-10· cited 35×
- Irvin v. IrvinSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1895-07-18· cited 26×
- Second National Bank v. YeagerSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1920-06-26· cited 25×
- Evans v. EdelsteinSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1923-02-26· cited 23×
- Bokser v. LewisSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1956-01-03· cited 18×
- Manley v. ManleySuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1976-02-02· cited 17×
- Seaboard Radio Broadcasting Corp. v. YasskySuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1954-08-30· cited 14×
- Potter v. GrimmSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1915-03-15· cited 13×
- Wright v. Monongahela Natural Gas Co.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1896-07-16· cited 9×
- Bessen Bros. v. BrooksSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1954-08-30· cited 9×
- Meyer v. W. R. Grace & Co.E.D. Pennsylvania· 1976-10-29· cited 4×
- Butler v. KellerSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1902-03-14· cited 3×
- Miles v. WaggonerSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1903-10-05· cited 3×
- Fidelity Trust Co. v. KohnSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1904-03-14· cited 3×
- Trexler v. ReynoldsSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1910-07-20· cited 3×
Cites
3 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Other cases named Irvin v. Irvin
6 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- Irvin v. IrvinSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1895-07-18· cited 26×
- Irvin v. IrvinSupreme Court of Kansas· 1958-03-08· cited 15×
- Irvin v. IrvinCourt of Appeals of Arkansas· 1994-10-05· cited 11×
- Irvin v. IrvinMissouri Court of Appeals· 1962-05-05· cited 10×
- Irvin v. IrvinMichigan Court of Appeals· 1979-11-20· cited 8×
- Irvin v. IrvinDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 2011-12-07· cited 1×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.