Interstate Commece Commission v. Northern Pacific Railway Co.

Citations

• 216 U.S. 538

Syllabus

<p>Under § 4 of the act of June 29, 1906, c. 3591, 34 Stat. 589, giving the Interstate Commerce Commission power to establish through routes and joint rates where no reasonable or satisfactory through , route exists, the existence of such route may be inquired1 into by the courts, notwithstanding a finding by the' commission.</p> <p>When one through route exists which.is reasonable and satisfactory, the fact that the public would prefer a second which is no shorter or better cannot overcome the natural interpretation of a provision in the statute to the effect that jurisdiction exclusively depends upon the fact that no reasonable or satisfactory route exists.</p> <p>As the Northern Pacific route from the points named to points between Portland and Seattle is reasonable and satisfactory, the fact that there are certain advantages in the Union Pacific or Southern route does not give the Interstate Commerce Commission jurisdiction to establish the latter as a through route against the objection . of the Northern Pacific Railway Company.</p>