Skip to main content

Citations

  • 1 MacA. Pat. Cas. 286

Syllabus

<p>Filing a'second application after interference — status of. — The filing of a second application by the defeated party to an interference is in effect an effort to have the decision reviewed and reversed upon a rehearing or new trial of the first case; and from the refusal of the Commissioner to declare a new interference thereon between the same parties no appeal lies to the judge.</p> <p>Rehearing — new trials — not appealable. — Motions to rehear in chancery and for new trials at law are motions addressed to the discretion of the court, from the refusal to grant which there lies no appeal.</p> <p>Section 8, act oe 1836, construed. — There is nothing in section 8 of the act of 1836 which makes it imperative upon the Commissioner to declare as many interferences between the same parties as the defeated party may seek by filing successive applications. The words of the law are satisfied by giving one trial between the same parties upon the same subject-matter.</p> <p>One trial only- by law as a bight op cause. — One full, fair, and impartial trial between the same parties and for the same matter of controversy is all that any citizen can claim under this statute or any other law known or practiced by the courts of this country.</p> <p>Sm — new trial upon motion — discretion op tribunal. — If such a trial has . not been had, the remedy is by rehearing or new trial, or some equivalent proceeding in the tribunal when the first trial took place. The sound discretion of that tribunal must be invoked ; and from its refusal to interfere there is no appeal.</p> <p>Sm — power op commissioner. — The Commissioner of Patents, up to the moment of issuing the patent, has the discretion to rehear a case before decided by him, and ought to do so until his mind is convinced that the patent is to issue to the true inventor.</p> <p>Sm — Sm.—Iiis discretion ought to he governed by the rules of law; and I know no better guide for him than the rules and principles applicable in courts

Judges: Dunlop

Read full opinion on CourtListener

Other cases with this name

Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).

This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.