In re Chambers

Citations

• 1 MacA. Pat. Cas. 641
• 5 F. Cas. 424

Syllabus

<p>OpPICE PBAOTICE — POKMS OP PROCEDURE IN THE OPPICE — NOT APPEALABLE.— As the manner in which the Commissioner shall aid the inventor — by information and suitable references, so as to assist his judgment in determining whether he shall persist in or abandon his claim — is submitted to the discretion of the Commissioner, no appeal lies from his action in this regard to the Circuit Court.</p> <p>Novelty. — The invention compared with patent to Alexander Douglass, April, 21st, 185T, (No. IT,082,) and English patent 2513, of 1856, and found not to be anticipated.</p>