Ninth Circuit· 8/19/2011
In Re Bluetooth Headset Products Liability
Citations
- 654 F.3d 935
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that participation of a mediator is not dispositive, but is “a factor in favor of a finding of non-collusiveness”
- recognizing that courts have discretion to choose either method as a primary basis for calculation, provided they exercise their discretion “so as to achieve a reasonable result”
- holding that district courts should “award only that amount of fees that is reasonable in relation to the results obtained,” even where counting all hours reasonably spent would produce a larger fees award
- holding that when parties seek approval of a settlement negotiated 17 prior to formal class certification, “there is an even greater potential for a breach of 18 fiduciary duty owed the class during settlement”
- noting that upon remand the district court may uphold the settlement notwithstanding the presence of all three of the Bluetooth warning signs
- noting that a percentage-of-recovery fee award is calculated by taking a percentage of the “common fund for the benefit of the entire class ” (emphasis added)
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Michael Daly Hawkins and Raymond C. Fisher, Circuit Judges, and Jack Zouhary
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
104 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Theodore H. Frank v. Netflix, Inc.Ninth Circuit· 2015-02-27· cited 313×
- Robert Radcliffe v. Experian Information SolutionsNinth Circuit· 2013-04-22· cited 258×
- Ginger McCall v. Facebook, Inc.Ninth Circuit· 2012-09-20· cited 249×
- In Re National Football League Players Concussion Injury LitigationThird Circuit· 2016-04-18· cited 217×
- Harry Dennis v. Stephanie BergNinth Circuit· 2012-09-04· cited 166×
- Laffitte v. Robert Half International Inc.California Supreme Court· 2016-08-11· cited 157×
- Robert Briseno v. Conagra Foods, Inc.Ninth Circuit· 2021-06-01· cited 140×
- Bellinghausen v. Tractor Supply Co.N.D. California· 2015-03-20· cited 138×
- Ontiveros v. ZamoraE.D. California· 2014-10-08· cited 135×
- Margie Bedolla v. Labor Ready Southwest, Inc.Ninth Circuit· 2015-06-02· cited 127×
- Millan v. Cascade Water Services, Inc.E.D. California· 2015-10-08· cited 106×
- Amber Gascho v. Global Fitness Holdings, LLCSixth Circuit· 2016-05-13· cited 102×
- Kent Eubank v. Pella CorporationSeventh Circuit· 2014-06-02· cited 90×
- Nicklos Ciolino v. Theodore FrankNinth Circuit· 2013-05-15· cited 88×
- Campbell v. Facebook, Inc.Ninth Circuit· 2020-03-03· cited 84×
- Monterrubio v. Best Buy Stores, L.P.E.D. California· 2013-05-14· cited 72×
- In re Toys \R\ US-Delaware, Inc.C.D. California· 2014-01-17· cited 70×
- Levitt v. Southwest Airlines Co.Seventh Circuit· 2015-08-20· cited 68×
- Stephen Stetson v. West Publishing Corp.Ninth Circuit· 2016-05-11· cited 67×
- Josue Romero v. Provide Commerce, Inc.Ninth Circuit· 2018-10-03· cited 63×
Cites
36 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Hensley v. EckerhartSupreme Court· 1983-05-16· cited 17,202×
- Amchem Products, Inc. v. WindsorSupreme Court· 1997-06-25· cited 4,991×
- Alyeska Pipeline Service Co. v. Wilderness SocietySupreme Court· 1975-05-12· cited 4,586×
- Pennsylvania v. Delaware Valley Citizens' Council for Clean AirSupreme Court· 1986-07-02· cited 1,746×
- Hanlon v. Chrysler Corp.Ninth Circuit· 1998-06-09· cited 1,381×
- Kerr v. Screen Extras Guild, Inc.Ninth Circuit· 1975-11-28· cited 1,048×
- Staton v. Boeing Co.Ninth Circuit· 2003-04-29· cited 1,028×
- In Re General Motors Corporation Pick-Up Truck Fuel Tank Products Liability Litigation. Jack French, Robert M. West, Charles E. Merritt, Gary Blades, Dawn and Tracey Best, Gary and Jackie Barnes, Betty Marteny, John and Mary Southands, Edmund Berning, Dale W. Plummer, Edmund and Anneta Casey, John aThird Circuit· 1995-04-17· cited 850×
- In Re: The Prudential Insurance Company Of America Sales Practices LitigationThird Circuit· 1998-07-23· cited 840×
- Rodriguez v. West Publishing Corp.Ninth Circuit· 2009-04-23· cited 648×
- Vizcaino v. Microsoft Corp.Ninth Circuit· 2002-05-15· cited 515×
- Evans v. Jeff D. Ex Rel. JohnsonSupreme Court· 1986-06-09· cited 504×
- Fed. Sec. L. Rep. P 98,755, Fed. Sec. L. Rep. P 99,074 William B. Weinberger v. James C. Kendrick, Charles M. CoyneSecond Circuit· 1983-01-26· cited 443×
- Six (6) Mexican Workers v. Arizona Citrus Growers Bodine Produce Company, Inc. Robert Fletcher, D/B/A Fletcher FarmsNinth Circuit· 1990-05-18· cited 441×
- Scott Fischer v. sjb-p.d. Inc., a California Corporation, Dba Cedar Creek Inn Svenja Bienlefeld Michael ViliunasNinth Circuit· 2000-06-15· cited 420×
- Unnamed caseNinth Circuit· 2000-06-19· cited 391×
- Archdiocese of Milwaukee Supporting Fund, Inc. v. Mercury Interactive Corp.Ninth Circuit· 2010-08-18· cited 341×
- Unnamed caseNinth Circuit· 1982-09-21· cited 337×
- Unnamed caseNinth Circuit· 1994-03-23· cited 303×
- Rufus E. Cunningham v. County of Los Angeles, and Richard Eiden, Real-Party-In-Interest-AppellantNinth Circuit· 1989-06-20· cited 289×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.