Illinois Ex Rel. Dunne v. Economy Light & Power Co.

Citations

• 234 U.S. 497
• 34 S. Ct. 973
• 58 L. Ed. 1429
• 1914 U.S. LEXIS 1104

Syllabus

<p>The provisions in the Ordinance for Government of the Northwest Territory and subsequent acts of Congress to the effect that navigable waters leading into, the Mississippi and St. Lawrence rivers shall be common highways and forever free to the inhabitants of that Territory and of the United States do not determine navigability of any of the streams but only definó rights dependent upon the existence of navigability.</p> <p>There is no Federal right involved in the obstruction, or use by private owners, of a non-navigable stream wholly within a State.</p> <p>The question of navigability of a river wholly within a State is purely one of fact, and where the state court has decided that such a river is non-navigable there is no right left to review.</p> <p>A State has no Federal rights which it may exert for itself or on behalf ■ of its citizens or of All the citizens of the United States in regard to a ' river wholly within its boundaries which the highest court of the State has declared to be non-navigable; nor are any such rights created by acts of Congress merely authorizing surveys for and estimates of cost of, improvements and not actually authorizing or appropriating for the same.</p>