Hubbell v. United States
Citations
- 179 U.S. 77
- 21 S. Ct. 24
- 45 L. Ed. 95
- 1900 U.S. LEXIS 1848
Syllabus
<p>An examination of the history of the appellant’s claim, shows that in order to get his patent he was. compelled to accept one with a narrower claim than that contained in his original application; and it is well settled that the claim as allowed must he read and interpreted with reference to the rejected claim and to the prior state of the art, and cannot be so construed as to cover either what was rejected by the Patent Office, or disclosed by prior devices.</p> <p>This court concurs with the court below in holding thát the cartridges made and used by the United States were not within the description contained in the appellant’s claim.</p>
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- using prosecution history to construe the claim and finding no infringement, without discussing prosecution history estoppel
- using prosecution history to construe the claim and finding no infringement, without discussing prosecution history estoppel
- patentee estopped from excluding a claim element where element was added to overcome objections based on lack of novelty over prior patents
- patentee estopped from excluding a claim element where element was added to overcome objections based on lack of novelty over prior patents
- “ ‘[A]ll [specified elements] must be regarded as material,’ ” though it remains an open “'question whether an omitted part is supplied by an equivalent device or instrumentality’ ” (citation omitted)
- “If it be a claim to a combination, and be restricted to specified elements, all must be regarded as material, leaving open only the question whether an omitted part is supplied by an equivalent device or instrumentality.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Shiras
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
100 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Warner-Jenkinson Co. v. Hilton Davis Chemical Co.Supreme Court· 1997-03-03· cited 1,430×
- Schriber-Schroth Co. v. Cleveland Trust Co.Supreme Court· 1940-12-09· cited 262×
- Exhibit Supply Co. v. Ace Patents Corp.Supreme Court· 1942-03-02· cited 221×
- Hilton Davis Chemical Co. v. Warner-Jenkinson Company, Inc.Federal Circuit· 1995-08-08· cited 220×
- I. T. S. Rubber Co. v. Essex Rubber Co.Supreme Court· 1926-11-22· cited 202×
- Festo Corporation v. Shoketsu Kinzoku Kogyo Kabushiki Co., Ltd., A/K/A Smc Corporation, and Smc Pneumatics, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2000-11-29· cited 196×
- Smith v. Magic City Kennel Club, Inc.Supreme Court· 1931-02-25· cited 133×
- Deere & Co. v. Bush Hog, LLCFederal Circuit· 2012-12-04· cited 110×
- Weber Electric Co. v. E. H. Freeman Electric Co.Supreme Court· 1921-06-06· cited 84×
- Computing Scale Co. of America v. Automatic Scale Co.Supreme Court· 1907-02-25· cited 83×
- Keystone Driller Co. v. Northwest Engineering Corp.Supreme Court· 1935-01-07· cited 67×
- Bryan W. Nickerson, Jr. v. The Bearfoot Sole Company, Inc., the Bearfoot Airway Corporation,defendants-AppellantsSixth Circuit· 1963-01-10· cited 33×
- Hazeltine Corporation v. Radio Corporation of AmericaS.D. New York· 1931-09-14· cited 32×
- Zoltek Corporation, Plaintiff-Cross v. United StatesFederal Circuit· 2006-03-31· cited 30×
- Power Curbers, Inc. v. E. D. Etnyre & Co. And A. E. Finley & Associates, Inc.Fourth Circuit· 1962-01-03· cited 26×
- Henry J. Kaiser Company v. McLouth Steel Corp.E.D. Michigan· 1966-07-06· cited 22×
- Gulf States Utilities Co. v. StateCourt of Appeals of Texas· 1932-01-13· cited 21×
- The Taylor-Reed Corporation v. Mennen Food Products, Inc., American Home Products Corporation, and Frederick C. MennenSeventh Circuit· 1963-11-08· cited 20×
- Shakespeare Co. v. Perrine Mfg. Co.Eighth Circuit· 1937-07-01· cited 19×
- St. Louis Street Flushing Mach. Co. v. American Street Flushing Mach. Co.Eighth Circuit· 1907-10-22· cited 19×
Cites
7 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Morgan Envelope Co. v. Albany Perforated Wrapping Paper Co.Supreme Court· 1894-03-19· cited 196×
- Knapp v. MorssSupreme Court· 1893-11-20· cited 174×
- Shepard v. CarriganSupreme Court· 1886-02-01· cited 152×
- Sargent v. Hall Safe & Lock Co.Supreme Court· 1885-03-30· cited 93×
- Leggett v. AverySupreme Court· 1880-02-18· cited 85×
- Water-Meter Co. v. DesperSupreme Court· 1880-04-26· cited 78×
- Hubbell v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1898-05-31· cited 41×
Other cases named Hubbell v. United States
2 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.