Houghton v. Burden
Citations
- 228 U.S. 161
- 33 S. Ct. 491
- 57 L. Ed. 780
- 1913 U.S. LEXIS 2361
Syllabus
<p>Where a secured creditor voluntarily comes into the Bankruptcy Court and asserts a claim to property in the trustees’ possession, the proceeding is one in equity and the decree is reviewable by the Circuit Court of Appeals both as to law and fact; § 566, Rev. Stat., is inapplicable and the whole case is open under § 128, Judicial Code, and an appeal lies to this court under § 241, Judicial Code.</p> <p>A contract for loaning money secured by accounts payable to the borrower, who is to act as agent for the lender in their collection, providing that the lender shall, in pursuance of a provision in a bond of indemnity given by-third parties, examine the accounts and books of the borrower monthly and receive a compensation therefor equivalent to a specified per cent' of the accounts remaining due, held in this case to have been made in good faith and not for the purpose - of avoiding the usury laws, and not to be a usurious and void contract under the laws of the State of New York.</p> <p>On an inquiry whether the contract is one forbidden by law, evidence ■dehors the agreement is admissible to show that, though legal on its ' face, the agreement is in fact illegal.</p> <p>Usury may be interposed as a defense even though it contradicts the agreement.</p> <p>Where the law of the state makes usury'a crime, the burden is strongly oh him who would avoid a debt on that ground; and where, as in this case,'the borrower is supported by one witness who is in his employ and the lender is supported by. one disinterested witness, the burden is not. sustained.</p>
Judges: Lurton, Pitney
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
41 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Taubel-Scott-Kitzmiller Co. v. FoxSupreme Court· 1924-04-07· cited 304×
- Taylor v. VossSupreme Court· 1926-05-03· cited 132×
- Lazarus, Michel & Lazarus v. PrenticeSupreme Court· 1914-06-08· cited 95×
- Central Republic Bank & Trust Co. v. CaldwellEighth Circuit· 1932-04-22· cited 56×
- Home Bond Co. v. McChesneySupreme Court· 1916-01-10· cited 39×
- Noteman v. WelchFirst Circuit· 1939-12-22· cited 38×
- In Re Gustav Schaefer Co.Sixth Circuit· 1939-04-13· cited 32×
- Robert Moody & Son v. Century Savings BankSupreme Court· 1915-12-20· cited 31×
- General Motors Acceptance Corp. v. Mid-West Chevrolet Co.Tenth Circuit· 1933-06-22· cited 18×
- Century Savings Bank v. Robt. Moody & SonEighth Circuit· 1913-12-11· cited 15×
- In Re PrinceSecond Circuit· 1937-05-03· cited 13×
- In re LarkeyD. New Jersey· 1914-05-27· cited 13×
- M. Lowenstein & Sons, Inc. v. British-American Mfg. Co.Second Circuit· 1925-04-06· cited 11×
- Clark v. HuckabyEighth Circuit· 1928-08-14· cited 10×
- Hardware Mut. Ins. Co. of Minnesota v. Jacob Hieb, Inc.Eighth Circuit· 1945-01-08· cited 10×
- Medical Arts Bldg. Co. v. Southern Finance & Development Co.Fifth Circuit· 1929-01-07· cited 9×
- Home Building & Savings Ass'n v. ShotwellSupreme Court of Arkansas· 1931-04-27· cited 9×
- Spain v. TalcottAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1915-01-22· cited 9×
- Ringer v. Virgin Timber Co.E.D. Arkansas· 1914-04-08· cited 9×
- Stark v. Bauer Cooperage Co.Sixth Circuit· 1925-01-06· cited 7×
Cites
5 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Coder v. ArtsSupreme Court· 1909-04-05· cited 276×
- Hewit v. Berlin MacHine WorksSupreme Court· 1904-05-16· cited 199×
- Knapp v. Milwaukee Trust Co.Supreme Court· 1910-03-07· cited 62×
- Campbell v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1912-03-18· cited 40×
- White v. BenjaminNew York Court of Appeals· 1893-04-25· cited 31×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.