Highmark, Incorporated v. Upmc Health Plan, Incorporated

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• stating “on an application for preliminary injunction, the plaintiff need only prove a prima facie case, not a certainty that he or she will win”
• stating “on an application for preliminary injunction, the plaintiff need only prove a prima facie case, not a certainty that he or she will win”
• “The Ad dealt with the scope and services offered by the insurers to their subscribers and thus concerned the ‘business of insurance.’”
• “The equitable doctrine of unclean hands applies when a party seeking relief has committed an unconscionable act immediately related to the equity the party seeks in respect to the litigation.”
• defense of unclean hands was not barred because the plaintiff ran an offending advertisement two years before the defendant’s advertisement, but because a nexus between the plaintiffs advertising and the defendant’s wrong was lacking
• upholding injunction ordering health insurer to publish corrective advertisement

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).