Harris v. Rosenberger
Citations
- 145 F. 449
- 13 L.R.A.N.S. 762
- 1906 U.S. App. LEXIS 3987
Syllabus
<p>1. Courts — Jurisdiction—Distribution Between Supreme Court and Circuit Courts of Appeals — Oases Involving Constitutional Questions.</p> <p>A suit, although not one of diversity of citizenship, which, according to the complainant’s bill, depends not only upon the construction and application of the Constitution of the United States and the constitutional validity of an act of Congress, but also upon the proper construction of tlie act of Congress, is one in respect of which the appellate jurisdiction of the Supreme Court is not exclusive, and an appeal from the final decree mav be taken to the Circuit Court of Appeals. Spreckles Sugar Refining Co. v. McClain, 24 Sup. Ct. 376, 192 U. S. 397, 407, 18 L. Ed. 496, followed.</p> <p>[Ed. Note. — Jurisdiction of cases involving federal questions, see notes to Bailey v. Mosher, 11 C. C. A. 308; Montana Ore Purchasing Co. v. Boston & M. C. C. S. Min. Co., 35 C. C. A. 7.</p> <p>Jurisdiction of Supreme Court and of Circuit Court of Appeals, see note to Lau Ow Bew v. United States, 1 C. O. A. 5.]</p> <p>2. Same — To Give Right to Direct Appeal to Supreme Court Constitutional Question Must be Real and Substantial</p> <p>Not every assertion of a right under some claimed construction or application of the Constitution, nor every claim that a pertinent act of Congress is violative of the Constitution, is efficient to establish a right to a direct appeal to the Supreme Court, under the statute distributing the appellate jurisdiction between that court and the Circuit Court of Appeals. The claim must be real and substantial, not merely colorable or without reasonable foundation.</p> <p>3. Same — Constitutional Question Ceases to be Real and Substantial After it has been Solemnly and Directly Determined by Supreme Court.</p> <p>Whether the question of the construction or application of the Constitution, or of the constitutional validity of an act of Congress, is real and substantial, or is merely colorable and without reasonable f
Judges: Devanter
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
23 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Levering & Garrigues Co. v. MorrinSupreme Court· 1933-04-10· cited 405×
- Somali Development Bank v. United StatesCourt of Claims· 1974-12-18· cited 139×
- Harrison v. United StatesSixth Circuit· 1912-12-03· cited 75×
- Bettman v. United StatesSixth Circuit· 1915-07-20· cited 51×
- Chambers v. United StatesEighth Circuit· 1916-10-30· cited 44×
- Harper v. United StatesEighth Circuit· 1944-06-30· cited 36×
- Jeffries v. OlesenS.D. California· 1954-05-13· cited 21×
- Sparks v. United StatesSixth Circuit· 1917-05-08· cited 19×
- Rude v. United StatesTenth Circuit· 1935-01-09· cited 18×
- Wine v. United StatesEighth Circuit· 1919-09-01· cited 11×
- United States of America and United States Postal Service v. International Term Papers, Inc.First Circuit· 1973-05-03· cited 10×
- In re Can PonNinth Circuit· 1909-02-23· cited 9×
- United States v. WhitmoreS.D. California· 1951-05-21· cited 7×
- Rider v. United StatesEighth Circuit· 1906-11-05· cited 6×
- McGowan v. ParishSupreme Court· 1913-04-14· cited 5×
- Donnell Mfg. Co. v. WymanU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Eastern Missouri· 1907-09-02· cited 5×
- Sanden v. MorganS.D. New York· 1915-06-07· cited 5×
- United States v. Roy M. Bloom, Philip Polishook, Roy M. Bloom, Inc. And K. Polishook & Son Corp.Second Circuit· 1956-09-11· cited 3×
- Branaman v. HarrisU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Western Missouri· 1911-05-25· cited 3×
- Hooper v. RemmelEighth Circuit· 1908-11-20· cited 2×
Cites
23 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Newburyport Water Co. v. NewburyportSupreme Court· 1904-04-04· cited 337×
- Wilson v. North CarolinaSupreme Court· 1898-03-21· cited 111×
- Union & Planters' Bank v. MemphisSupreme Court· 1903-04-13· cited 66×
- New Orleans Waterworks Co. v. LouisianaSupreme Court· 1902-05-05· cited 53×
- Miller v. United StatesEighth Circuit· 1904-11-11· cited 43×
- Horman v. United StatesSixth Circuit· 1902-06-03· cited 42×
- McCain v. Des MoinesSupreme Court· 1899-05-01· cited 31×
- Huguley Manufacturing Co. v. Galeton Cotton MillsSupreme Court· 1902-02-24· cited 27×
- O'Hara v. United StatesSixth Circuit· 1904-05-04· cited 27×
- Weeber v. United StatesU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Colorado· 1894-06-15· cited 26×
- Kansas v. BradleyU.S. Circuit Court· 1885-12-31· cited 22×
- Filhiol v. MauriceSupreme Court· 1902-04-07· cited 15×
- Montana Ore-Purchasing Co. v. Boston & M. C. C. & S. Min. Co.Ninth Circuit· 1898-02-28· cited 11×
- Sawyer v. PiperSupreme Court· 1903-04-27· cited 9×
- Missouri Drug Co. v. WymanU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Eastern Missouri· 1904-05-09· cited 9×
- Blue Bird Min. Co. v. LargeyU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Montana· 1892-02-03· cited 6×
- Fairfield Floral Co. v. BradburyU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Maine· 1898-09-06· cited 5×
- Rosenberger v. HarrisU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Western Missouri· 1905-04-24· cited 4×
- Arkansas v. Choctaw & M. R.U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Eastern Arkansas· 1905-01-13· cited 4×
- Myrtle v. Nevada, C. & O. Ry. Co.U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Nevada· 1905-04-22· cited 3×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.