Hamilton v. Foster
Citations
- 272 Pa. 95
- 116 A. 50
- 1922 Pa. LEXIS 782
Syllabus
<p>Lease — Oil and gas lease — Minerals ferae naturae — Mines and mining — Contracts—Construction—Duty of lessees — Damages— Burden of proof — Mistahe in boring — Injunction—Discretion— Reservation — Royalties—Maxims—Mquitas sequntur legem.</p> <p>1. As between the parties to a grant of oil and gas in place, a conveyance thereof is binding and effective, even though they may escape and be lost before being reduced to absolute possession.</p> <p>2. The fact that water and oil, and still more strongly gas, may be classed as minerals ferse naturae, does not determine they are not capable of ownership when in place and may not be made the subject of a grant.</p> <p>3. Oil and gas are minerals, while in place are part of the land exactly like other minerals, and may be leased separate and apart from the surface of the land and from other minerals beneath it.</p> <p>4?. All written instruments relating to a particular kind of business must be construed with due regard to the known characteristics of the business.</p> <p>5. The fact that there is a distinction, upon questions of interpretation, between an oil and gas lease and other leases, has no relation to the interest or estate conveyed; the dominion of the owner is as absolute over the fluid as over the solid minerals.</p> <p>6. It is the duty of the lessee in a gas lease to promptly locate and drill wells on the leased property, with due regard to similar operations on adjoining lands.</p> <p>7. Where by a trespass one obtains possession of property which is his, damages for the trespass cannot be measured by the value of the property.</p> <p>8. Wben tbe lessee of a property and all tbe gas and oil under it, in good faith and in the belief that be has tbe right so to do, bores a well at a point forbidden by tbe lease and obtains gas therefrom, tbe mistake in boring at that point does not operate to retransfer to tbe lessor tbe title to the gas.</p> <p>9. An injunction will be granted only as a matter of grace in tbe
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- In the words of an old maxim, “Cujus est solum, ejus est usque ad coelum et ad inferos,” or, “To whomsoever the soil belongs, he owns also to the sky and to the depths.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Frazer, Kephart, Moschzisker, Sadler, Schaefer, Simpson, Walling
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
16 cases in this archive cite this case.
- United States Steel Corp. v. HogeSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1983-12-22· cited 46×
- Erie City v. Public Service CommissionSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1924-01-07· cited 41×
- In Re Estate of QuickSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2006-08-23· cited 35×
- Bannard v. New York State Natural Gas Corp.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1972-06-28· cited 29×
- White v. New York State Natural Gas CorporationW.D. Pennsylvania· 1960-12-29· cited 21×
- Duquesne Natural Gas Co. v. FefoltSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1964-03-19· cited 19×
- Maxler v. Freeport BankSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1923-01-03· cited 18×
- United States Steel Corp. v. HogeSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1982-08-27· cited 13×
- J. William Winney, Jr. v. Michael Troy JerupWyoming Supreme Court· 2023-11-28· cited 13×
- Ventresca v. VentrescaSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1956-11-13· cited 11×
- New York State Natural Gas Corp. v. Swan-Finch Gas Development Corp.W.D. Pennsylvania· 1959-03-31· cited 6×
- Briggs v. Southwestern Energy, Aplt.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2020-01-22
- Kowalczyk v. BuyanoskiLuzerne County Court of Common Pleas· 1958-11-07
- Searfoss v. Whitehaven Borough School DistrictLuzerne County Court of Common Pleas· 1959-06-16
- McCray v. HarrisCrawford County Court of Common Pleas· 1927-12-19
- McManus v. AcklinWashington County Court of Common Pleas· 1947-08-18
Cites
13 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Westmoreland N. Gas Co. v. DeWittSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1889-11-11· cited 114×
- Brown v. SpilmanSupreme Court· 1895-01-14· cited 69×
- Kleppner v. LemonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1896-07-15· cited 46×
- Marshall v. MellonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1897-01-04· cited 45×
- Wettengel v. GormleySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1894-04-02· cited 34×
- McKnight v. Manuf. N. Gas Co.Washington County Court of Common Pleas· 1892-01-04· cited 25×
- Appeal of StoughtonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1879-01-06· cited 23×
- McIntosh v. RoppSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1912-01-02· cited 17×
- Prager's EstateSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1920-07-14· cited 15×
- Burgan v. South Penn Oil Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1914-01-05· cited 12×
- Highfield Co. v. KirkSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1915-01-11· cited 11×
- Kier v. PetersonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1862-03-22· cited 9×
- Kelly v. Phillips Gas & Oil Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1918-10-23· cited 2×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.