Guidesoft, Inc. D/B/A Knowledge Services v. State Protest Committee, State of Tennessee

Syllabus

This appeal concerns a bid protest. UWork.com, Inc., d/b/a Covendis Technologies (\Covendis\) successfully bid on a contract to manage a network of temporary workers for the State of Tennessee. Guidesoft, Inc. d/b/a Knowledge Services (\Knowledge Services\), an unsuccessful bidder, filed a protest with the Central Procurement Office (\the CPO\). The CPO dismissed Knowledge Services' bid for insufficient bond. Knowledge Services appealed to the State Protest Committee (\the Committee\), which denied the appeal. Knowledge Services then filed a petition for common law writ of certiorari in the Chancery Court for Davidson County (\the Trial Court\). After a hearing, the Trial Court dismissed Knowledge Services' amended petition. Knowledge Services now appeals to this Court, arguing that under Tenn. Code Ann. § 12-3-514(d), its protest bond should be based on 5% of the lowest evaluated cost proposal rather than 5% of the State's estimated maximum liability as found below. We hold, inter alia, that the protest bond statute is meant to protect the State, and the appropriate protest bond amount is based on the costs the State may incur rather than a bidder's proposed cost. Further, the fee relied upon by Knowledge Services to calculate its protest bond is but a small portion of the contract at issue, which is estimated to cost the State $190,000,000. The Committee did not exceed its jurisdiction or act illegally, arbitrarily, or fraudulently. We affirm the Trial Court.