Gostina v. Ryland
Citations
- 116 Wash. 228
- 199 P. 298
- 18 A.L.R. 650
- 1921 Wash. LEXIS 824
Syllabus
<p>Adjoining Landowners (3)—Encroachments. An adjoining property owner having an absolute legal right, under Rem. Code, § 943, to an action to abate a nuisance caused by overhanging branches of trees, the defendants cannot defend on the ground that the action is inspired by spite.</p> <p>Nuisance (5)—Private Nuisance—Grounds for Injunction. Acquiescence for several months in a nuisance occasioned by overhanging branches and the spreading vines of a creeping plant would not constitute an estoppel against a right of action by an adjoining owner to abate the nuisance occasioned thereby. ■</p> <p>Estoppel (48)—Equitable Estoppel—Acquiescence—Laches. In an action to abate a nuisance under Rem. Code, § 943, granting the right where there is an obstruction to the free use of property essentially interfering with the enjoyment of life and property, proof of some actual and sensible damages, although insignificant, will sustain plaintiff’s right to have the nuisance abated.</p> <p>Mackintosh and Bridges, JJ., dissent.</p>
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- concluding that needles falling from overhanging branches causing additional maintenance are “actual, sensible damages”
- overhanging branches constitute a nuisance only when they do sizeable or substantial harm
- the fact that damages resulting from a nuisance 20 may be insignificant in amount goes to the extent of recovery, and not the right of action
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Holcomb, MacKintosh
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
24 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Arnold v. MelaniWashington Supreme Court· 1968-02-21· cited 99×
- Michalson v. NuttingMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1931-04-02· cited 48×
- Lane v. WJ. Curry & SonsTennessee Supreme Court· 2002-12-19· cited 36×
- Jones v. WagnerSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1993-04-29· cited 36×
- Sterling v. WeinsteinDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 1950-07-13· cited 28×
- Whitesell v. HoultonHawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals· 1981-08-27· cited 27×
- Holmberg v. BerginSupreme Court of Minnesota· 1969-12-05· cited 26×
- Abbinett v. FoxNew Mexico Court of Appeals· 1985-07-09· cited 24×
- Cannon v. DunnCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 1985-03-28· cited 22×
- Olivia & William Herring Et Ux v. Jose & Blanca Pelayo, Et UxCourt of Appeals of Washington· 2017-05-02· cited 21×
- Smith v. HoltSupreme Court of Virginia· 1939-11-20· cited 21×
- Melnick v. C.S.X. Corp.Court of Appeals of Maryland· 1988-05-06· cited 14×
- Garcia v. SanchezNew Mexico Court of Appeals· 1989-03-16· cited 13×
- Jennifer Mustoe v. Xiaoye Ma And Anthony JordanCourt of Appeals of Washington· 2016-04-04· cited 11×
- Pierce v. CasadyCourt of Appeals of Kansas· 1985-12-31· cited 9×
- Alvarez v. KatzSupreme Court of Vermont· 2015-06-19· cited 9×
- Jurgens v. WieseNebraska Supreme Court· 1949-06-29· cited 8×
- Melnick v. C.S.X. Corp.Court of Special Appeals of Maryland· 1986-11-10· cited 3×
- Alan R. Atkins et al. v. Marie F. Adams et al.Supreme Judicial Court of Maine· 2023-08-29· cited 3×
- Iny v. CollomAppellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York· 2006-08-15· cited 2×
Cites
4 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.