Gordon v. Ware Nat. Bank
Citations
- 132 F. 444
- 67 L.R.A. 550
- 1904 U.S. App. LEXIS 4338
Syllabus
<p>1. Live Insurance — Insurable Interest — Requisite to Validity.</p> <p>The issue of a policy of life insurance to one who has no interest as a relative, dependent, creditor, or otherwise, in the life of the insured, and who pays the premiums for the chance of recovering upon the policy, is against public policy, and the contract is void, because the interest of the holder is to shorten, rather than to lengthen, the life of the insured, and his maintenance of the policy is of the nature of a wager.</p> <p>2. Same — Creditor has Insurable Interest.</p> <p>A creditor has an insurable interest in the life of his debtor, and the issue or pledge of a policy upon his life as collateral security for the payment of his debt is valid.</p> <p>5. Same — Necessity oe Insurable Interest in Assignee — Question oe General Daw.</p> <p>The question whether or not an insurable interest in an assignee is requisite to the validity of the assignment of a policy of life insurance, which was originally issued to one who had an insurable interest, is a question of general law, upon which the decisions of the courts df the state in which the assignment was made are not controlling in the federal courts.</p> <p>t Same — Assignment Valid Without Insurable Interest in Assignee.</p> <p>An insurable interest in the assignee is not requisite to the validity of the assignment of a policy of life insurance which was lawfully issued to one who had such an interest, unless the assignment was made in bad faith as a cover for the issue of a wager policy. But the use of an assignment immediately upon the issue of a policy to evade the rule that the issue of a policy to one without an insurable interest renders it void avoids the assignment..</p> <p>o. Same — Pledgee oe Policy May Sell to One Without Insurable Interest.</p> <p>The pledgee of a policy of life insurance has the right and power to sell the policy to the highest bidder for the purpose of realizing money to pay the debt which it secures, an
Judges: Amidon, Devanter, Sanborn
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
26 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Clegg v. United StatesTenth Circuit· 1940-06-10· cited 36×
- Vermillion v. Spotted ElkNorth Dakota Supreme Court· 1957-10-14· cited 32×
- Lincoln Nat. Life Ins. Co. v. ScalesFifth Circuit· 1933-01-13· cited 27×
- Citizens Nat. Bank of Orange, Va. v. WaughFourth Circuit· 1935-06-03· cited 27×
- Russell v. GrigsbySixth Circuit· 1909-03-22· cited 22×
- PHL Variable Insurance Company v. Bank of UtahEighth Circuit· 2015-03-13· cited 14×
- Clark v. BeltEighth Circuit· 1915-03-16· cited 12×
- Butterworth v. Mississippi Valley Trust Co.Supreme Court of Missouri· 1951-06-11· cited 11×
- Swift v. JacksonTenth Circuit· 1930-01-02· cited 11×
- In re OrearEighth Circuit· 1910-02-23· cited 11×
- Odegard v. General Casualty & Surety Co.Eighth Circuit· 1930-09-08· cited 10×
- Bendet v. EllisTennessee Supreme Court· 1907-12-15· cited 10×
- McWilliams v. BlackardEighth Circuit· 1938-04-28· cited 9×
- Mutual Aid Union v. WhiteSupreme Court of Arkansas· 1924-12-01· cited 8×
- Dakota Life Ins. Co. v. Midland Nat. Bank of MinneapolisEighth Circuit· 1927-04-12· cited 7×
- Linton v. Omaha Wholesale Produce Market House Co.Eighth Circuit· 1914-10-26· cited 6×
- Farmers & Merchants Bank v. Crafty Fox, Ltd. (In Re Crafty Fox Ltd.)W.D. Virginia· 1980-02-06· cited 5×
- Jack v. HoodTenth Circuit· 1930-03-21· cited 4×
- Fay Heasley, Selma Heasley, Helen Heasley Herr, Paul Heasley, Pearl Heasley Hendrix v. The United States of AmericaEighth Circuit· 1965-07-16· cited 3×
- Lawrence v. Travelers Ins. Co.E.D. Pennsylvania· 1934-03-16· cited 3×
Cites
29 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Cromwell v. County of SacSupreme Court· 1877-04-16· cited 2,216×
- Warnock v. DavisSupreme Court· 1882-03-18· cited 256×
- Connecticut Mutual Life Insurance v. SchaeferSupreme Court· 1877-04-30· cited 216×
- Board of Com'rs v. PlattEighth Circuit· 1897-03-22· cited 85×
- Clement v. Insurance Co.Tennessee Supreme Court· 1898-04-16· cited 73×
- Aetna Life Ins. Co. v. FranceSupreme Court· 1877-05-18· cited 57×
- Mutual Life Insurance v. AllenMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1884-10-24· cited 56×
- Speer v. Board of County Com'rsEighth Circuit· 1898-06-20· cited 56×
- Cammack v. LewisSupreme Court· 1873-04-28· cited 55×
- Schonfield v. TurnerCourt of Appeals of Texas· 1889-12-06· cited 49×
- Franklin Life Insurance v. HazzardIndiana Supreme Court· 1872-11-15· cited 40×
- Brown v. Greenfield Life Ass'nMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1899-02-28· cited 38×
- Succession of A. Constant HearingSupreme Court of Louisiana· 1874-04-15· cited 36×
- Rittler v. SmithCourt of Appeals of Maryland· 1889-02-21· cited 34×
- Clapp v. Otoe CountyEighth Circuit· 1900-10-09· cited 32×
- Crosswell v. Connecticut Indemnity Ass'nSupreme Court of South Carolina· 1897-11-09· cited 28×
- Curtiss v. Ætna Life InsuranceCalifornia Supreme Court· 1891-07-17· cited 24×
- Milner v. BowmanIndiana Supreme Court· 1889-06-22· cited 24×
- Gilbert v. Moose's AdministratorsSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1883-05-31· cited 20×
- Murphy v. RedMississippi Supreme Court· 1887-04-15· cited 16×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.