Federal Circuit· 8/11/2005
Freedman Seating Co. v. American Seating Co.
Citations
- 420 F.3d 1350
- 76 U.S.P.Q. 2d (BNA) 1001
- 2005 U.S. App. LEXIS 16778
- 2005 WL 1903786
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that to constitute infringement under the doctrine of equivalents, the accused product must contain each limitation of the claim or its equivalent
- holding that a limitation was vitiated in part because the structural difference in the accused device “is not a ‘subtle difference in degree,’ but rather ‘a clear, substantial difference or difference in kind’ ” (internal citation omitted)
- concluding that “an element of an accused prod- uct or process is not, as a matter of law, equivalent to a limitation of the claimed invention if such a finding would entirely vitiate the limitation”
- finding that a rotatably mounted support member on a stowable seat was not equivalent to a slidably mounted support member
- holding there is not equivalence as a matter of law “if such a finding would entirely vitiate the limitation”
- explaining that in order to prove infringement, a patent holder must show that the accused device contains each element, literally or by equivalence, of the asserted claim
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Mayer, Plager, Schall
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
98 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Pfizer, Inc. v. Teva Pharmaceuticals Usa, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2005-11-22· cited 165×
- Cordis Corp. v. Boston Scientific Corp.Federal Circuit· 2009-03-31· cited 139×
- Depuy Spine, Inc. (Formerly Known as Depuy Acromed, Inc.) v. Medtronic Sofamor Danek, Inc. (Formerly Known as Sofamor Danek Group, Inc.)Federal Circuit· 2006-11-20· cited 101×
- Trading Technologies International, Inc. v. eSpeed, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2010-02-25· cited 91×
- Carnegie Mellon University v. Hoffmann-La Roche Inc.Federal Circuit· 2008-09-08· cited 72×
- TIP Systems, LLC v. Phillips & Brooks/Gladwin, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2008-06-18· cited 69×
- Ball Aerosol & Specialty Container, Inc. v. Limited Brands, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2009-02-09· cited 65×
- Duncan Parking Technologies v. Ips Group, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2019-01-31· cited 64×
- TecSec, Inc. v. International Business MacHines Corp.Federal Circuit· 2013-10-02· cited 55×
- New Tek Mfg., Inc. v. BeehnerNebraska Supreme Court· 2008-06-27· cited 44×
- Primos, Inc. v. Hunter's Specialties, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2006-06-14· cited 42×
- Ortho-Mcneil Pharmaceutical, Incorporated v. Caraco Pharmaceutical Laboratories, LimitedFederal Circuit· 2007-01-19· cited 42×
- Tessera, Inc. v. International Trade CommissionFederal Circuit· 2011-05-23· cited 38×
- Huawei Techs., Co. v. Samsung Elecs. Co.N.D. California· 2018-09-25· cited 28×
- Cross Medical Products, Inc. v. Medtronic Sofamor Danek, Inc. And Medtronic Sofamor Danek Usa, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2007-03-20· cited 26×
- PSN ILLINOIS, LLC v. Ivoclar Vivadent, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2008-05-06· cited 23×
- Changzhou Kaidi Electrical Co. v. Okin America, Inc.D. Maryland· 2015-04-29· cited 19×
- LG Electronics, Inc. v. Bizcom Electronics, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2006-07-07· cited 18×
- Ca, Inc. v. Simple. Com, Inc.E.D. New York· 2009-03-05· cited 15×
- Hitkansut LLC v. United StatesFederal Claims· 2016-05-11· cited 12×
Cites
20 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc.Supreme Court· 1986-06-25· cited 135,235×
- Graham v. John Deere Co. of Kansas CitySupreme Court· 1966-02-21· cited 3,371×
- Graver Tank & Mfg. Co. v. Linde Air Products Co.Supreme Court· 1950-10-09· cited 1,620×
- Warner-Jenkinson Co. v. Hilton Davis Chemical Co.Supreme Court· 1997-03-03· cited 1,430×
- Festo Corp. v. Shoketsu Kinzoku Kogyo Kabushiki Co.Supreme Court· 2002-05-28· cited 669×
- Cardinal Chemical Co. v. Morton International, Inc.Supreme Court· 1993-05-17· cited 519×
- Sage Products, Inc. v. Devon Industries, Inc., Defendant/cross-AppellantFederal Circuit· 1997-09-18· cited 434×
- Pennwalt Corporation, Appellant/cross-Appellee v. Durand-Wayland, Inc., Appellee/cross-AppellantFederal Circuit· 1987-11-06· cited 390×
- Ellison v. RobertsonNinth Circuit· 2004-02-10· cited 337×
- Dr. Raymond G. Tronzo v. Biomet, Inc.Federal Circuit· 1998-10-19· cited 162×
- Johnson & Johnston Associates Inc. v. R.E. Service Co., Inc. And Mark FraterFederal Circuit· 2002-03-28· cited 139×
- Lockheed Martin Corporation v. Space Systems/loral, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2003-03-24· cited 130×
- Moore U.S.A., Inc.,plaintiff-Appellant v. Standard Register Company,defendant-CrossFederal Circuit· 2000-09-22· cited 128×
- Typeright Keyboard Corporation v. Microsoft Corporation, Defendant-CrossFederal Circuit· 2004-07-06· cited 115×
- Wright Medical Technology, Inc. And Dow Corning Corp. (Formerly Dow Corning Wright Corp.) v. Osteonics CorporationFederal Circuit· 1997-08-27· cited 87×
- Rf Delaware, Inc. v. Pacific Keystone Technologies, Inc., Bca Industrial Controls (1995) Limited, Clearwater Technologies, Inc., and Michael MorrisFederal Circuit· 2003-04-21· cited 86×
- Frank's Casing Crew & Rental Tools, Inc. v. Weatherford International, Inc., Defendant-CrossFederal Circuit· 2004-11-30· cited 71×
- Kustom Signals, Inc. v. Applied Concepts, Inc. And John L. AkerFederal Circuit· 2001-09-05· cited 69×
- Asyst Technologies, Inc. v. Emtrak, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2005-03-22· cited 40×
- Hughes Aircraft Co. v. United StatesFederal Circuit· 1998-04-07· cited 38×
Other cases named Freedman Seating Co. v. American Seating Co.
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.