Franklin v. Shelton

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• concluding lay witness was not competent to testify about her son’s broken ribs and punctured lung because she was not capable of observing those injuries
• explaining that “where injuries complained of are of such character to require skilled and professional persons to determine the cause and extent thereof, they must be proved by the testimony of medical experts”
• explaining that “where injuries complained of are of such character to require skilled and professional persons to determine the cause and extent thereof, they must be proved by the testimony of medical experts.”
• “These evidentiary principles apply, of course, to ADA claims.”

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

37 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• Tesone v. Empire Marketing Strategies
  Tenth Circuit· 2019-11-08· cited 236×
• Jung Ja Malandris v. Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith Incorporated
  Tenth Circuit· 1983-03-31· cited 162×
• Barnes v. Smith
  Tenth Circuit· 1962-06-04· cited 94×
• E.G. Thompson and Betty Thompson v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Company
  Tenth Circuit· 1994-08-09· cited 89×
• Catherine B. Ramsey v. Charles H. Culpepper and the Farmington Investment Company
  Tenth Circuit· 1984-07-05· cited 88×
• Richfield Oil Corporation v. Karseal Corporation
  Ninth Circuit· 1959-10-13· cited 59×
• Hull v. Sun Refining and Marketing Co.
  Supreme Court of Oklahoma· 1990-05-03· cited 43×
• Dunn v. St. Louis-San Francisco Railway Co.
  Tenth Circuit· 1966-12-12· cited 43×
• Vincent Chiodo v. General Waterworks Corporation, a Corporation
  Tenth Circuit· 1967-07-03· cited 38×
• T. Dean Brown v. Richard H. Wacholz, Inc., D/B/A Silver King Motor Inn
  Tenth Circuit· 1972-11-08· cited 37×
• Harry Henry and Robert E. Braye, Jr. v. A/s Ocean and John P. Pederson & Sons, and Third-Party & v. Pittston Stevedoring Corporation, Third-Party
  Second Circuit· 1975-01-06· cited 31×
• Ziegler v. Akin
  Tenth Circuit· 1958-11-15· cited 30×
• Robert J. Cleary, by His Father and Next Friend, Mike Cleary, Sr. v. Indiana Beach, Inc., a Corporation
  Seventh Circuit· 1960-04-13· cited 29×
• Byrne v. Matczak
  Third Circuit· 1958-04-23· cited 26×
• Community National Life Insurance Company, an Insurance Corporation v. Parker Square Savings and Loan Association, a Corporation
  Tenth Circuit· 1969-01-29· cited 24×
• Merle H. McDonald and Stella McDonald v. United Airlines, Inc., a Delaware Corporation, and Alan G. Rutherford
  Tenth Circuit· 1966-09-26· cited 22×
• John C. Rogers, and the Hartford Accident & Indemnity Company, in Intervention v. Northern Rio Arriba Electric Cooperative, Inc., a Corporation
  Tenth Circuit· 1978-08-09· cited 22×
• Yeager v. Durflinger
  Supreme Court of Iowa· 1979-05-30· cited 20×
• Garland Coal & Mining Co. v. Few
  Tenth Circuit· 1959-05-27· cited 20×
• Glen W. Ketchum v. Anna J. Nall
  Tenth Circuit· 1970-05-04· cited 18×

Cites

19 cases in this archive are cited by this case.

• Chicago & N. W. Ry. Co. v. Green
  Eighth Circuit· 1947-10-27· cited 73×
• Lucille M. Rankin, Administratrix on the Estate of Ronald Rankin, Deceased v. Shayne Brothers, Inc., Billy F. Rankin v. Shayne Brothers, Inc.
  D.C. Circuit· 1956-04-23· cited 43×
• Gillette Motor Transport, Inc. v. Northern Oklahoma Butane Co.
  Tenth Circuit· 1950-01-05· cited 33×
• E. L. Farmer & Company, a Corporation v. Marshall W. Hooks and American Motorists Insurance Company
  Tenth Circuit· 1957-03-25· cited 32×
• Grant E. Hayes v. United States of America, (Two Cases). Ronald J. McDonald v. United States of America, (Two Cases)
  Tenth Circuit· 1956-11-17· cited 29×
• Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific Railway Company, a Corporation v. Raymond C. Kifer
  Tenth Circuit· 1954-11-26· cited 22×
• W. W. Clyde & Co. v. Dyess
  Tenth Circuit· 1942-02-26· cited 20×
• Thiringer v. Barlow
  Tenth Circuit· 1953-06-22· cited 18×
• Spivey v. Atteberry
  Supreme Court of Oklahoma· 1951-09-18· cited 17×
• Cushing Coca-Cola Bottling Co. v. Francis
  Supreme Court of Oklahoma· 1952-06-03· cited 17×
• Purington Paving Brick Co. v. Metropolitan Paving Co.
  Eighth Circuit· 1925-03-07· cited 15×
• Niagara Fire Ins. Co. v. Muhle
  Eighth Circuit· 1953-12-31· cited 13×
• General Electric Co. v. Save Sales Co.
  Sixth Circuit· 1936-03-06· cited 13×
• James I. Barnes Const. Co. v. Hargrove
  Supreme Court of Oklahoma· 1934-01-16· cited 10×
• Smith v. Cox
  Supreme Court of Oklahoma· 1956-09-18· cited 8×
• Tom Reed Gold Mines Co. v. Berd
  Arizona Supreme Court· 1927-10-17· cited 6×
• United States v. Monger
  Tenth Circuit· 1934-04-10· cited 6×
• United States v. Woltman
  D.C. Circuit· 1932-02-29· cited 4×
• Prudential Ins. Co. of America v. Bialkowski
  Fourth Circuit· 1936-10-06· cited 2×

Other cases named Franklin v. Shelton

2 other CourtListener records share this case name.

• Franklin v. Shelton
  Tenth Circuit· 1958-03-03· cited 3×
• Franklin v. Shelton
  Supreme Court· 1958-03-03